I had a good time with Leap of Faith, and found myself entertained and engaged during the vast majority of its duration, so I can definitely recommend it and mark it as worthy of your time and money.
With that said, I need to refer to all these outstanding reviews talking about an experience, and using very flattering words (this is the reason why I tried it really, Leap of Faith is a title completely outside of my comfort zone, when it comes to adult games).
This is a story that used convenient amnesia, suicide with no lasting consequences, bad guys having a change of heart after one talk, convoluted spy stuff and surpassing one hardship, as an entire character arc.
Let me be blunt, if a kid eats at McDonald's and claims that's the best food in the entire world, you don't take it seriously, even if the food does taste pretty good.
I feel like I got my hopes up, only to surmise that some of these opinions likely come from people who never read a book, or a visual novel, or even a light novel (in other words, a very limited perspective).
Now I think it's great that this story had an impact on them, and I wanted to experience something similar, but it didn't happen (I do understand that any expectations are my own issue, but there you have it).
Let me start with the good:
- Leap of Faith is really funny - It's not the best kind of humor, but it's up there. Silly, non-sequitur, avoids toxicity, makes easy to understand references, not pretentious. I almost cried (from laughter) at the "fast food cook protagonist" with Samantha. Priceless. The high point of the story.
- Leap of Faith gives the illusion of choice - It does feel like you are leading things towards one of the girls, instead of just picking her events all the time (a major problem in visual novels that makes things "mechanic"). So in my case I ended up with Cece, and wasn't exactly happy about it, but it did feel like my choices lead to the protagonist's behavior. That's a very good thing.
- Leap of Faith has a stupid (it's a positive) amount of slice of life - It's the same principle behind watching a soap opera, or a long running show, at some point you just enjoy their interactions, and become interested in what they are doing by default.
- Leap of Faith has all the girls bringing something to the table - That means all of them do enough to be interesting. Crudely you have: The ex, the crazy one, the superstar, the high school crush, the rebellious phase one and her partner, and the ginger. It's a good mix and in the end they are all "diamonds in the rough" (very nice people, with problems to overcome). Can't ask for much more, the sense of picking the right person is there.
- Leap of Faith has the best friend and the "rejected" romantic cast do their own thing - This was refreshing. I'm fine with the universe delivering all the girls to the protagonist on a silver platter. I'm not fine when after the choice is made, everyone is left "hanging" except the main couple. Leap of faith has the characters moving on, and do their thing, that's great.
The not so good:
- The music - It's not the choice of music itself, it's the lyrics, they are distracting, and make immersion more difficult. I would prefer more tracks with no singing, save those for more dramatic moments. Turning the music off doesn't make it better, I want some audio. This one is completely personal and subjective, but I still have to mention it.
- Character development - Most of them have two modes: Party/funny and "currently contemplating hardships/feeling down". This is a major problem, because outside of backstory everyone feels the same, talks the same, and reacts the same. Excessive character tropes in fiction exist for a reason. That reason is going from extreme to normality and provide a sense of depth and empathy towards a "living" character. None of that here.
Cece (my choice) has nothing going for her, other than pity for her situation and being hot (Yes, looks are very important, I'm not even sorry). She is the same from start to finish and saying that there's a lot on her mind and she's very troubled all the time only goes so far. Try to justify why the protagonist likes her (sex with her does count as a reason, but it's not enough). I can't. It's the mystery of LOVE.
- Persona 4 Syndrome (Important: I love Persona 4) - Facing ONE problem and overcoming it, means very little in real life. Realizing the truth of the universe, your role in life, and what's really important, means very little in real life. The real difficulty is maintaining it on your brain long enough that it actually becomes the norm instead of an enlightened moment, and that's because we are hardwired (biologically) to run on "auto-pilot" most of the time.
Translation: Realizing something is 10% of the difficulty, putting it into practice is 80%. Life screwing with you, fills the rest. The story has some life coach speeches that make everything OK, and it's disappointing (again reviews, expectations).
- The Cellphone tasks - No idea what is up with that but at some point I just began ignoring them. If you have a "quest like mechanic" make it understandable. If the idea is to experience different things with multiple playthroughs, then it doesn't work for me. One run did the trick.
- Romanticized ideas on the value of being special/unique - I'm not gonna explore this, but let me be clear, telling someone that they are special, that they deserve something by default, or that they can achieve anything if they try, is one of the reasons that leads to some of the situations I saw in the story. It's an authentic poison that Leap of Faith decides to perpetuate.
You DON'T need to be special to have value, you NEED to work (hard) for your happiness, and there's a distinct possibility that you might FAIL at one of your life goals. How many depressions could have been avoided with that mindset? I get it, it's entertainment, life through a screen. The lack of reflection and self-thought, makes me genuinely sad.
I could go on, but what's important is to notice, is how much I wrote about Leap of Faith. I'm not giving this one a score, what I will tell you is that you should try it (definitely), and make up your own mind. I for one I'm tired of people echoing the same old ideas and concepts on all kinds of media, that have no translation to real life, though I will admit that I had some fiction change my viewpoints in the past, so I can understand the role Leap of Faith served to some of its reviewers.