make the MC a monster directly to reconcile both aspect. That gnoll that captured Gabrielle back in the second game had a funnier story than whatever happened in the main plot of that game. Make it about growing your monster gang, capturing girls and taking over the world one dicking at a timeAnd maybe playing as a female MC, which I always say fits better witch what Gabe actually wants the story to be about, sluts getting raped or fucking animals and monster, instead of a male MC which fits with the games starting out as something inspired by old school adult JRPGs self-insert power fantasy.