- Aug 23, 2023
- 1,791
- 8,660
I could say so much stuff. But I'm just glad I'm here rather than there. What a peculiar place
Edit: I find it hard to fathom a list where Ayane is best girl even if it was manipulated by Himawari.
Edit: I find it hard to fathom a list where Ayane is best girl even if it was manipulated by Himawari.
- Jan 14, 2021
- 886
- 2,623
Heh the bottom of the list is 3 adults, then Nodoka, then 3 more adults. Also Kaori being that low means they all have no taste.
- Oct 1, 2023
- 718
- 1,683
Didn't expect the general audience to get it, but yes, Ayane IS the best girl, and she is the one meant to be
- Aug 20, 2022
- 200
- 1,171
Tbf, I can kind of get behind this list.
It's not exactly that close to mine, but I can at least understand why it looks like this.
The "problem" with averages is always that results will get kind of muddled. Or in other words, controversial characters will get very high votes, but also very low votes.
In the end, the top characters will be the ones that the least amount of players truly hate.
And from that perspective, the results absolutely make sense. The top contenders are just genuinely kind and affectionate girls that are not overly complicated for the player and that everyone can get behind (pun intended in this case).
I'd say after the top half you can notice there starting to be more divisive and complex characters, among literal children.
Basically, if you look at the bottom 15, they are basically all either children, rather boring characters (Futaba, Karin, Otoha, Maki, Osako) or very intimidating (Chika, her recent developments are visible here I feel, Yuki, Nodoka, Tsubasa) and also very justifiably Haruka, who I would be very surprised if anyone listed anywhere near their top 10 (Apologies if you do).
- Oct 1, 2023
- 718
- 1,683
I don't care about your analysis Haruka fucking sucks and Osako needs to get hit by Sekai's car
- Aug 20, 2021
- 776
- 4,223
The Persona 5 Halloween outfits in the previews inspired me to put this one together:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Why do people hate Osako? I get the Haurka and Tsubasa hate, and wholeheartedly believe the game would be significantly better if Nodaka wasn't in it, so I get why they're all at the bottom. But was surprised to see Osako there.
- Aug 20, 2022
- 200
- 1,171
Osako has been widely considered a bit of a bland and spineless character whose main character traits seemed to be being Wakana's lesbian girlfriend and therefore also being one of the few females not at all interested in Akira.
I personally don't hate her and wouldn't want her gone, but I also find it hard to come up with arguments for why she could be someone's favorite.
But I have to praise Sel here for a moment, as I feel he has addressed her character development, or lack thereof, and tried to flesh her out a little bit recently. He made Akira acknowledge her value for being a potentially good friend, exactly for the reason that they would not be into each other. And her becoming a bit more proactive and independent, making sound decisions and genuinely trying to better herself finally. I find what's going on between her and Akira is becoming really wholesome and is hopefully developing into a kind of buddy relationship that he intended to find in Imani (who I feel is in turn stalling now in her character development). Also he fixed her hair, she is cute now.
Regarding Nodoka, by the way, I would definitely disagree with you though. I personally also don't like her personality at all, as in, I would absolutely not want to be friends with, let alone be romantically involved with, a person like her. But she is unique in many ways.
First off with her connections to other characters, not only the main 20 + 15 side characters, but more notably to more mysterious characters. But also with her immense world knowledge and neurotic and obsessive view on and approach to things. She could become a crucial character in the plot and would be absolutely missing if she somehow vanished.
Also, any good story should always include unlikable people.
Which also means that I actually don't hate any character currently in LiL. Which is a testament to the writing. While I dislike a few of the girls, or even gods, involved in the story, they all play a vital role and the game would be worse off without them.
- Jun 24, 2020
- 913
- 3,174
This is fan-fucking-tastic. I love it. 15/10 no notes.
- May 27, 2020
- 1,235
- 8,858
Even outside the game Noriko is #2. At this point it's gotta be a bit.
- Oct 5, 2019
- 61
- 164
Understandable. Let's see what happens once the less developed girls get more time in. Who is most likely to stay where they are? (Osako). Who is most likely to climb? (Kaori)
And hasn't this list forgotten someone? (Sekai
- Oct 15, 2019
- 737
- 776
You forgot cat lines! It should complain about it's being late and that they should go to sleep.
- Apr 30, 2018
- 48
- 116
The discord has a terminal case of shit taste.
- Aug 13, 2024
- 518
- 1,004
when did this tread become a argument about who is best girl the answer is obviously chika/miku/sana sorry maybe picking best girl is harder than i thought
- Mar 15, 2023
- 1,038
- 2,038
How can it be easy if you failed?when did this tread become a argument about who is best girl the answer is obviously chika/miku/sana sorry maybe picking best girl is harder than i thought
- Aug 13, 2024
- 518
- 1,004
Maya is the only girl i feel like i had pure thoughts about. Everyone else felt like a conquest of some kind and thats great and all. But something about maya feels balanced. Like a real person if thats odd to say. I KNOW that she will be worth it. So much so that even small gains feel immensely impactful.
Normally when sensei holds himself back from doing something i groan at it because it feels out of character for him to be so weak willed.
But with maya i truly dont think i could hurt her if i had the option. There is just something... Pure isnt the word. Untainted?
Sacred.
I truly would enjoy just sitting and talking with her probably forever.
Everyone else feels corrupted or like part of the flow.
But Maya just feels like the only other thing staying above the water with me. Even if everything breaks I would be ok knowing at least she is there.
So in terms of "Best" I would always say her.
Normally when sensei holds himself back from doing something i groan at it because it feels out of character for him to be so weak willed.
But with maya i truly dont think i could hurt her if i had the option. There is just something... Pure isnt the word. Untainted?
Sacred.
I truly would enjoy just sitting and talking with her probably forever.
Everyone else feels corrupted or like part of the flow.
But Maya just feels like the only other thing staying above the water with me. Even if everything breaks I would be ok knowing at least she is there.
So in terms of "Best" I would always say her.
- Dec 29, 2019
- 1,842
- 2,030
Cause she pretty much is. She's the only one of the girls whose relationship predates the simulation. Everyone else has the same issue of being compelled to fuck sensei for reasons they don't know about. Add on a star crossed lovers tragic backstory where she waited several years to find you again and you want to root for her. Then have her be deleted in the same way you were and all of a sudden you want to white knight and return the favor.
Even underneath their personalities of being assholes there's true love there.
Shes also one of the only ones whos dialogue i dont mostly skip because she has no sex scenes.
Im still human after all and i find it a waste to listen to anyone who isnt available.