Yesterday I played the new game
The Best of Intentions.
In a nutshell, it's a father-daughter incest game with a very slutty daughter.
You can read my review
here but that's not the point of this thread.
I was a bit "suprised" about the NTR flak that the game got in the thread, although at the start of the game there is no sexual relationship between the father and the daughter.
IRL, it is quite normal that a daughter has sex with different guys. As a father you may like that or (more likely) not, but there is not so much you can do about that besides trying to raise her well.
With guys (male protagonist games) on the other hand, it seems completely acceptable that the MC has sex with all girls in the game. It is even expected of all those girls to stay loyal to the MC even though he's not loyal to them.
I believe that in general there is a difference how society perceives Male sluttiness (cool guy or even "alpha male") vs. Female sluttiness (slut, whore, cumdump).
On the other hand it seems to be also expected of "popular girls" to "put out" on dates, but not too much or too fast otherwise she's clearly a "slut" whereas males don't have this problem. The only problem guys have is that they are perceived as "not cool" if they are "still" a virgin at age X.
Any thoughts on this matter?
I think it comes down to who is the protagonist and the circumstances of the story, that determines what type of immersion and/or relatability effects the VN/Game will have on the reader/player...
The protagonist has the greatest impact, especially in Choice based VN/Games... Because you are adding another level of immersion for the reader/player, that will have a greater effect on their emotional investment... Not always, but a majority of the time the reader/player wants to be the one catching all the breaks, and winning over all the lust and love interests... So if there is a character or characters getting in the way, then it is natural for both jealousy as well as anger to incur within the reader/player... Especially when, whom they perceive, as "their" protagonist gets cock/pussy blocked and/or similar emotional turmoil, causing the emotions to run high, which in turn may cause them to no longer want to read/play the story... And a lot of developers know this, so they try not to create friction between their product and the target audience...
So you get the protagonist usually being setup as the pervert of the story... And there seems to be a tendency in many cases for the developers out there to include some, slut style character personalities, around the protagonist... Typically because those types of characters are much easier targets for the protagonist, and/or is done in order to create an excuse for earlier erotic/porn scenes in a VN/Game... I think there is a tendency to do this in order to cater to the more instant gratification crowd, regardless if there are other characters with a slower work up to the sex stuff, or not...
Sometimes the protagonist is not only the pervert, but also the target of slut style corruption... Male or Female? That tends to be determined by the developer either based off their experiences or based off their relatability of telling the story in the first place...
This is also a male dominated industry when it comes to readers/players... So many a time, it is the same with the developer, and so they both relate easier with a male protagonist... Hence why you don't see as many Female Protagonist VN/Games... And a majority of the female protagonists you do see, she is the target of corruption or sexual promiscuity, rather then the one going after the targets and/or corrupting/seducing them... Another sign of a male dominated, and perhaps sometimes even sexist industry...
With the male dominance by both the developers and the readers/players, you get a tendency for more promiscuous style female characters over male characters... Stereotypical male sluts tend to be the young and slightly dumb jock, or mean spirited and abusive boyfriend/husband, who just want to bed as many women as possible... The stereotypical female slut tends to be the young super model style character who is either highly manipulative and craves sex constantly, typically either she is mean spirited or dumb as a rock... You also have the stereotyped older woman with either super huge breasts and butt or slightly larger breasts but looks younger then she should, who is either easy to manipulate because she is repressed sexually, or she is highly into her own sexuality and is ready to bed any cute guy who comes into her orbit... And the list goes on for both sexes...
I wouldn't call all the women or men in these VN/Games, who are slightly or highly over sexualized, as being sluts though... The very definition of slut is that they have a tendency to have casual sex with many various sex partners... So just because a character acts sexual and comes on to the protagonist very easily, or she is so comfortably with her own sexuality that she acts sexual towards a male/female character in the story quite often... That doesn't necessarily make him or her a slut... Some characters may just be licentious (promiscuous and unprincipled in sexual matters), with only one or very few sexual partners…
You can't always equate real life relevancy to what happens in a majority of these erotic/porn themed VN/Games... 9 times out of 10 these things are more about the fantasy of a situation rather then the reality of it... Adding some realism here and there, both into the story and character development, is always a plus... But to say what happens in these VN/Games and how quickly it sometimes happens has any basis on real life, that would be a very loose comparison most of the time... So in your analogy of the daughter and father, where the daughter may sleep around and that a father should come to terms with it... In real life, yes, that is how it tends or should tend to happen... But in the world of fiction, it isn't about reality, as that would be Non-Fiction... Relatability is nice to have in fiction, but whether that is related to the reality of a situation or the fantasy of a situation is entirely up to how the story is told and how the reader perceives it... It's a balance that is not always maintained or easy to maintain, for either side... But is so much more fun to read/play when it does, again depending on the person...
Zip