Damn, guys, you're really inspiring, maybe I should also put my LI database and ratings here, damn, something to think about, Mostly I were doing cards for myself and some of my friends, even hooked some of them on AVNs)))
Also, as for you ratings - I must say even though we not always share same opinion about best girls, I would say more or less out tastes are pretty similar. Also I can say - pretty often we like bad girls/tsundere (they're in our top-3 at least hahah).
From the games I played (played enough to make decisions) compared to yours:
- Radiant: Chelsey is also in my top-3
- Heart problems: Kylee is my fav with Amelie 2nd one
- Lancaster Boarding House: 1) Lisa 2) Abigail 3) Chloe (also why Lisa is considered a side girl, she has an ending, pretty wholesome one I must say, did Dev said anything?)
- Elite Garden: Kiara is my absolute #1, I also really like Jessica btw a lot (bartender), pity she is not a LI
- Through Spacetime: 1) Hitomi 2) Nicole 3) Eve (I wish though there were more content with Twiins, I liked Mary, but it's just too little content with them to make any harsh decisons)
- Where the heart is: Wanda is my absolute fav, nobody is close to her here
- Picture Perfect: Paris (her solo path the only one I consider decent, harem path is just... ridiculous from my perspective)
- College Kings: Nora, Aubrey and Lindsey are my 3 favs
- Secret Summer: Irene, Norah and Leanne for me