I mostly agree, except for Scarlett. She's like last year's snow, sitting in the freezer and constantly forced upon us by the developer, with no way to refuse, which, yes, makes the MC who knows what.
As for the NTR, if the MC once had sex with someone, that doesn't mean that woman is now exclusively his. Of course, if the MC really wants it. If he doesn't care, then what kind of NTR is this? It must be said that in previous versions this issue was turned upside down, and therefore the characters' reactions are completely inappropriate for the relationship. We'll see what happens next, but for now it feels like a farm where they milk sponsors

.