My wife cares
It's difficult to be "literally like a father to your sister
S" when you
literally (that is the correct use for that word) only have one. Or do you mean that the MC is a caring fatherly/husbandly figure?
(obviously kidding here)
Yes, it's my first game. Now you know. You could have known by reading the OP.
Blame it on my poor English, but the sentences which start with "But you better not..." always sound like a threat to me. I've done it in my first game and no one has died yet.
Have some players complained about the MC's apparent age? Yes.
Have some players complained about Erika having tats? Yes. She has them.
Have some players complained about Martha's looks? Yes, obviously. She doesn't sport a 64E.
Have some players complained about Norah's weight? Also yes. For some players, she has slimmed too much, for others too little.
Daphne's braid? Yes. Samantha and Simone's skin color? Yes. Alexia's birth country? Of course. Emma's hairstyle? Obviously (about the three of them)
Would players complain if I remove Erika's tats, give Martha a 64E, make a clone of Norah so there can be an anorexic and a fat one, change Daphne's braid, Samantha and Simone's race, Alexia's nationality, or Emma's hairstyle? I'm sure they will.
Hearing all players' opinions, but taking them with a grain of salt and heading them only when they make sense is one of the devs' jobs. Deciding when an opinion makes sense is another one.