- Feb 19, 2021
- 4,155
- 10,128
I've seen some people, and I really hope I'm not running afoul of rule 1 here, mostly a minority opinion within the BIPOC liberation movements insisting that I can't be Canadian because Canada is just a settler colonial fabrication and I'm instead whatever national ancestry I hold. Just absolutely wild to me. I've got absolutely zero connection to Europe, my entire life I've had no living ancestor who's from Europe, other than English I speak none of my ancestral languages, I have no connection to my familial roots in Europe and my paternal grandfather was a con artist who started at least 3 families with at least 2 fabricated names so I'm only even somewhat sure that my last name is the correct one. Like sure, I won't wade into the debate over how much Canada/US do or don't suck here but the claim that I can't be Canadian because of it is abso-fucking-lutely wild to me.What I never got is how some guy born and raised in Middle Earth (for example) can say he's Narnian only because 100 years ago (some of) his ancestors emigrated from Narnia to Middle Earth when he (and most of his ancestors since that) never visited Narnia. He's Middle Earthian to the bone! Perhaps his family or part of his neighborhood has kept some diluted Narnian habits and festivities, but that doesn't make him a Narnian.
My mother was born in Spanish Mordor and moved to the Eastern Ports when she got married. I never dared to say I'm Mordorian, even if we still kept some habits (habits, no hobbits) from there!
Also my best friend has a last name that basically means his family emigrated from Europe without a last name. These same people are claiming he can't be Canadian and he should identify with his ancestral roots when he has literally no way of even tracing those roots.