- Jun 20, 2022
- 6,708
- 11,161
Technically you're not wrong, but also technically you are.I think real story is with the incest patch on. So, Martha is indeed MC's mom and Scarlett is MC's half-sister.
I also think that both story are made canon for those who don't have an incest kink. So, basically you should stick with the version you like the most.
Trope is intentionally making both version as complete stories ... they're both still the same story, just from each "relationship tree"s point of view.
So if you play either version, it's a complete story with no (intentional) plot holes that would be filled if the relationship was different.
That said ... while the convolution factor is definitely decreased with one of the versions, the other can play nice with the
" 'thoraties," so there's that ...