YOUR mc xP others haven't even gotten out of the condom

True, I'm just going by the options presented to us. You're given the option to decide whether MC and Laura have had anal sex in the past, but the lack of unprotected sex is taken as a given, which doesn't ring true to me. I find it very hard to believe that a young couple who've been together for that long and have a very healthy sex life wouldn't have taken advantage of a safe day here and there to indulge in some condom-free sex.
But honestly? That is just a difference in perspective... for many the creampie is something special while anal is just a different form of sex.
Anal sex
is just a different form of sex, but I don't think there would be many people who would see it as less special than a creampie, at least in term of how common an occurrence it is in a relationship. That's just never been my experience, or that of my friends (the ones who talk about their sex lives at any rate), or indeed the majority of straight couples according to sex surveys.
The reason it sticks out to me is that the dev has obviously taken a more realistic approach to the writing of this game, especially with pacing (to a degree) and definitely with the descriptions of the sex. It's refreshing to see an AVN where the bull isn't some relentless fuck machine with hours of stamina and an endless amount of cum. So when I see something that I don't think holds true IRL, it takes me out of it.
I'd think creampie is more intimate because of the risk of pregnancy, and consequently more "taboo" to be doing it with others, but with the different contraceptive methods today, maybe it isn't that big of a deal indeed, even more so in games, that pregnancy doesn't happen unless dev wants it to happen. Hahaha
I'm not saying it isn't an intimate act (although sex itself is already intimate, regardless of feelings between the participants), I just think it's much more common to experience in relationships compared to anal sex, which is why it stands out to me in this game.