Oh yes, these are the guys who think that an aphrodisiac makes a girl/woman incredibly horny and eager for sex right here and now. You are wrong, the maximum that can be achieved is an increase in blood flow, hence an increase in sensitivity for the nerves, but for the skin it decreases. Do you want an incredibly horny girl? Just catch her at the moment of ovulation, you won't regret it. No time for waiting? Make the romantic atmosphere. No magic, no succubuss marks, no "drugs".
"These are the guys..." Aren't you a tad judgemental ? Should I kindly ask you to gtfo ? Or maybe it wasn't on purpose, and then I'll just ignore it and move on.
Are you... Using IRL shenanigans to prove a point about a mechanic in H-games ? Do you think I talk about IRL women ?
Usually, aphrodisiac in an H-game is akin to "magic" by how potent it is. We're not speaking about ginseng IRL, but demon semen based concoction or other weird stuff. I doubt the aphrodisiacs in Taimanin for exemple (or 9 out of 10 H-games from different licences where it is not just an item that boost a stats, but a narrative device) are mere bloodflow amplifier seeing how hard it breaks their mind.
If you were stating an IRL advice, I'm on board with you, anyday, you're right.
But if you think aphrodisiacs in H-game were designed to be just like those we have in our world when they are designed as a plot device and not a stats boost item, you're wrong.