Also have played all of them so I need more recommendations if you guys don't mind. Reckon I already squeezed this website of the specific genre I'm looking for right now.
I think you've run the well dry for sure. I also went looking for something similar not terribly long ago but couldn't find anything either. You could also try:
Portals of Phereon
and
Masters of Raana
I haven't played much of either, and what I have played was forever ago.
The only other option I can think of is
Free Cities. While not open world, it has some of the most comprehensive customization options in gaming. The link is to the dead original version, but there is a mod you can find. Because the mod has options for illegal content, you can't get it here. But if you want it, you can just search free cities, pregnancy and find the git. It may have started as a pregmod, but it has evolved far passed that now.