Faptime

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2018
1,777
4,039
I'm not unsympathetic to Marina's situation, but it's hard to support her actions here. It's not like those two assholes will leave her alone after this, so backing up Cat's story is not only the "right" thing to do, it's her best chance to eliminate the assholes once and for all. Yeah, it's a gamble, but doing nothing is a pretty big a gamble too, so why not at least ease your conscience in the process?
I think the Dev has done a good job of showing that Marina is a runner. She encounters problems, she runs. It's all she knows. It's going to be up to MC to show her a better way.
 

Avaron1974

Resident Lesbian
Aug 22, 2018
25,987
89,650
I'm with you for the dudes, but Marina was in such a terrible position.

Yes, my opinion of her dropped a lot when she was going to let the rapists have Cat and then threw Cat under the bus to Principal Prickface, but my dislike is tempered with a lot of empathetic pity.
If it was a little thing like detention then sure, i'd sympathise with Marina.

However, Cat is being shipped to the farm so Marina helped to ruin, maybe even end, her life. I can't feel any kind of empathy towards Marina for that.

It's going to be up to MC to show her a better way.
I'll help her pack.
 

Elduriel

Forum Fanatic
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
4,412
7,819
I'm with you for the dudes, but Marina was in such a terrible position.

Yes, my opinion of her dropped a lot when she was going to let the rapists have Cat and then threw Cat under the bus to Principal Prickface, but my dislike is tempered with a lot of empathetic pity.
it was a really sad scene overall. I really fucking hope MC stops being somewhat of a pussy and fucks those assholes up with his powers. Preferably along with Ruth. Would be a treat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rehwyn

Rehwyn

Active Member
Apr 10, 2024
880
1,410
it was a really sad scene overall. I really fucking hope MC stops being somewhat of a pussy and fucks those assholes up with his powers. Preferably along with Ruth. Would be a treat.
MC has been coasting and living the good life for several days now. This premonition is an excellent narrative device to get him motivated to start using his powers more and stepping into the "hero" role.
If it was a little thing like detention then sure, i'd sympathise with Marina.

However, Cat is being shipped to the farm so Marina helped to ruin, maybe even end, her life. I can't feel any kind of empathy towards Marina for that.

I'll help her pack.
The premonition ability creates some interesting moral questions. For example, if MC intervenes tomorrow before it even gets to the point of Marina facing that choice, is it really ethical to berate or punish that new "alt universe version" of Marina for something she now technically hasn't done?

Obviously it can still sour someone's perspective on them, but it does make it a much more complex question.

Edit: On an aside, I pretty much guarantee the principal knows what's up and if Marina had tried to stick up for Cat could have found herself on the way to the Farm too. I bet Marina suspected that and realized that trying to help at that point may have been a futile gesture.
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Chrisdarock19

Reniere

Well-Known Member
Aug 5, 2019
1,452
2,635
Everyone is talking about Cat and Marina but not about parker. Parker might be the biggest Villain in hiding with the shit she's pulling it looks

From what i can understand about Evelyn's powers is that you touch the person you want and you see 5hours of there life (assuming its a future seeing type of power) meaning Cat and Marina being put into that mess is not real time but going to happen. meaning it hasnt happened yet Mc can help stop it. unless im wrong. but from what we seen it might be a future based power.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroker Ace

Rehwyn

Active Member
Apr 10, 2024
880
1,410
Everyone is talking about Cat and Marina but not about parker. Parker might be the biggest Villain in hiding with the shit she's pulling it looks

From what i can understand about Evelyn's powers is that you touch the person you want and you see 5hours of there life (assuming its a future seeing type of power) meaning Cat and Marina being put into that mess is not real time but going to happen. meaning it hasnt happened yet Mc can help stop it. unless im wrong. but from what we seen it might be a future based power.
Parker is definitely doing things in secret. It remains to be seen what her motives are however.

As for Evelyn's power, she sees the full next day for that person, not just 5 hours. So yes, what MC saw at the end hasn't happened yet and can be changed by intervening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroker Ace

Avaron1974

Resident Lesbian
Aug 22, 2018
25,987
89,650
MC has been coasting and living the good life for several days now. This premonition is an excellent narrative device to get him motivated to start using his powers more and stepping into the "hero" role.

The premonition ability creates some interesting moral questions. For example, if MC intervenes tomorrow before it even gets to the point of Marina facing that choice, is it really ethical to berate or punish that new "alt universe version" of Marina for something she now technically hasn't done?

Obviously it can still sour someone's perspective on them, but it does make it a much more complex question.

Edit: On an aside, I pretty much guarantee the principal knows what's up and if Marina had tried to stick up for Cat could have found herself on the way to the Farm too. I bet Marina suspected that and realized that trying to help may have been a futile gesture.
I thought Evie's power showed what happened the day before not the next day meaning Cat has already been taken.

She didn't know he'd fucked Moonsong until after he'd done it.
 

ben_sylar

Member
Apr 26, 2019
292
608
Everyone is talking about Cat and Marina but not about parker. Parker might be the biggest Villain in hiding with the shit she's pulling it looks

From what i can understand about Evelyn's powers is that you touch the person you want and you see 5hours of there life (assuming its a future seeing type of power) meaning Cat and Marina being put into that mess is not real time but going to happen. meaning it hasnt happened yet Mc can help stop it. unless im wrong. but from what we seen it might be a future based power.
It is future based but the person you are seeing is seemingly chosen randomly among the people who you touched that day.
 

Rehwyn

Active Member
Apr 10, 2024
880
1,410
I thought Evie's power showed what happened the day before not the next day meaning Cat has already been taken.

She didn't know he'd fucked Moonsong until after he'd done it.
No, Evelyn's power is future premonition. It shows the next day for the person being scry'd, meaning that MC has the opportunity to intervene and prevent what he saw from happening.

What Evelyn saw the first time wasn't MC sleeping with Moonsong that first night, but his date with Moonsong and sleeping with her the next day.
It is future based but the person you are seeing is seemingly chosen randomly among the people who you touched that day.
It's random until you learn to control it. Then you can select the person you want to see by focusing on them at the time you touch them.
 

Faptime

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2018
1,777
4,039
Everyone is talking about Cat and Marina but not about parker. Parker might be the biggest Villain in hiding with the shit she's pulling it looks
Parker is my choice for being the one that shows MC that the MTF is corrupt and Moonsong's group is being used.

She's going to be the one that shifts the story from MC wanting all these powers to potentially be a hero, to MC needing all of these powers to stand up to the corrupt corporation.
 

ben_sylar

Member
Apr 26, 2019
292
608
I thought Evie's power showed what happened the day before not the next day meaning Cat has already been taken.

She didn't know he'd fucked Moonsong until after he'd done it.
She didn't host mc before so she didn't see him getting it on with moonsong. She touched moonsong and then dreamed of mc and moonsong getting it on after she left. That either means she went home and straight to bed or this is a plothole. Or I'm missign something.
 

satirious

Member
Mar 15, 2021
359
665
I thought Evie's power showed what happened the day before not the next day meaning Cat has already been taken.

She didn't know he'd fucked Moonsong until after he'd done it.
She saw Moonsong getting his sample, doing the testing, their date in Korea and the sex that followed. That's the day she saw. That's how she knows he manifested after she leaves with either the Evelyn or Moonsong choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rehwyn

Rehwyn

Active Member
Apr 10, 2024
880
1,410
She didn't host mc before so she didn't see him getting it on with moonsong. She touched moonsong and then dreamed of mc and moonsong getting it on after she left. That either means she went home and straight to bed or this is a plothole. Or I'm missign something.
This is correct, but what Evelyn saw from Moonsong's perspective was the date and sex the following day, not the sex that first night.

If you turn down Moonsong that first night, instead of being angry, Evelyn tells MC via Celeste the next morning that "I hope you enjoy your date with Moonsong. I know I did."
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ben_sylar

Elduriel

Forum Fanatic
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
4,412
7,819
Parker is my choice for being the one that shows MC that the MTF is corrupt and Moonsong's group is being used.

She's going to be the one that shifts the story from MC wanting all these powers to potentially be a hero, to MC needing all of these powers to stand up to the corrupt corporation.
potentially, but it's still a shitty thing to do to hide all that from him when she knows what's going on
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulPanzer83

Rehwyn

Active Member
Apr 10, 2024
880
1,410
I missed that, so Evelynn actually controls it? When did she say that?
I forget which Chapter (somewhere in 1, 2, or 3), but Evelyn explains that it took her months to learn to control her power, but now she can pick someone in advance by focusing on them when touching them, but once that choice is made for the day she can't change it. That's also how she tries to teach MC to use it in Chapter 5.

She cannot however choose no one, unless she literally touches no one that day. If she doesn't choose in advance, it's random for her again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ben_sylar

Reniere

Well-Known Member
Aug 5, 2019
1,452
2,635
I thought Evie's power showed what happened the day before not the next day meaning Cat has already been taken.

She didn't know he'd fucked Moonsong until after he'd done it.
Looks Like Marina can't be hated yet if it hasn't happened yet lol if its a next day thing.
emperor-palpatine-star-wars-evil-thinking-stare-3pqpl0nr089qum0e.gif
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,461
14,260
I think the Dev has done a good job of showing that Marina is a runner. She encounters problems, she runs. It's all she knows. It's going to be up to MC to show her a better way.
Yeah, she's a runner but that cuts both ways. The guy has her mom's number, so he's threat no matter what. If she backs up Cat's story now, it's not like she couldn't still run away later and there's a chance the threat from the asshole is neutralized. If she lies, she HAS to run away, and this threat is still active. Plus, you know, Cat is sent to the Farm for being raped; that minor issue.

The risk to Marina would be if she herself is detained by telling the truth and only by telling the truth, which seems unlikely. I appreciate that Marina's under a lot of stress here, but she's still making a deeply concerning decision and that's not something that will go away even if the MC manages to avert this. IMHO.



Other than that, it seems like the gameplay is rather limited if you make an 'ethical' playthrough, which is understandable but disappointing.
Wait, there's an ethical path?? :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: satirious
4.30 star(s) 84 Votes