- Jun 21, 2018
- 244
- 481
I agree that the gap is a huge issue, but it think the other problems are that beyond Ian she's not really all that pleasant to be around. She's stuck up, judgemental, and will often take over the conversation to complain about her problems, she comes of as a bit of a narcassist. My problem with her story come in 3 parts:Thank you for that! As a huge Alison Fan this is exactly how I view her Character as well and for me she still is the best (Endgame) Option for Ian even after Nine Chapters now! The big Problem with Alison for many people is that I think the gap between her Stories is too much (It's like between possible "Highschool-Big-Love-Story" and for the People who play not much Alison it's more like "Crazy Psycho who is obsessed with Ian"). I think the love Route with her is amazing and has like the most hottest but also realistic scenes (also the romance with her is build up very slow but again it feels realisitic) You can start hooking up with her in Chapter 2 and explore a lot of different takes with her Route and right now you still can't really confess to her if your Ian has Feelings for her because they are building this up every Chapter) I mean I also love Cindy but the Evolution of her Route espescially from Chapter 7 to 9 was way too fast and the Romance-Part of her Story doesn't feel right for me at least right now but on the other Hand the cheating part with her is really good so every possible Option has good Scenarios somehow for every taste.
I just feel like Alison is a better Mature-Visual-Novel than just pure Porn-Game Character because if you play all of her Scenes you definitely see she is really flawed and yes sometimes annoying (espescially if you don't pay much attention to her Route) but therefore also well written.
A. Ian has this internal conflict with having sex with a friend, but we as the player don't really get to experience much of that because we know Alison purely as an LI. Her story would have benefitted from taking some time to establish their friendship first before moving with the FwB, which also would help with my next points.
B. Her story is very romance driven, we don't really see scenes where she's just organically part of the story, which means we only very specific sides of her(compare this to Cindy or Emma, some of their scenes have nothing to do with their romance with Ian)
C. we're not really shown Alison in a more "relaxed" setting till the trip. she's kind of always in a bad mood, and this results her not being as dynamic and well rounded as other characters. Her path would have benefitted from implementing her into the group more, since they know her, that way we get to see an Alison who's around ppl she's comfortable with, giving her different dynamics with each group member so we get to see more of her(something like Anna from AeA as i feel their personalities are somewhat similar).
I do like her character though, she feels very authentic. I'm hoping with her romance path we start to see her get more and more relaxed with Ian, she seemed to be taking the first steps towards that during the trip letting go of her need to control things for a while.
Wouldn't necessarily say Cindy's story is rushed, her story necessitated an uptake in pace due to the nature of it:
- the cheating meant they had to really be drawn to one another and couldn't really have time to feel that out on "dates" or something similar
- her denial meant Ian had to go all in to get her to confess her feelings or not, plus Ian also has to feel it's worth the risk to go behind his friend's back to "be with" his girlfiriend
I don't really have a favoured romance myself, I think LenaxIan is the best written due to the nature of them being the obvious focus of the story but i do like the others as well(especially Holly's which has this kind of wierd power dynamic where i'm wondering if Ian should really pursue her since she puts him on this pedestal, she's a textbook Dandere, and it adds this complexity to a romance that seems like such an obvious choice).