Zeinhold

Member
Sep 20, 2017
225
539
Going to flat out admit that I love this game so far. Mina is definitely one of my top 5 3-D Waifu's. Hoping to see us go on that arcade date with her the next update. (And hang out with her little brother I suppose. Can't ignore the in-laws :p )
 

mrr9

New Member
Jan 7, 2018
12
115
In Game Mod for Ch3Up1 - Shows toughness and relationship changes of different options. Also has gallery unlocker. I just stumbled upon this game today, and have not yet completed it - let alone taken any potential different paths; so apologies if you hit any bugs, but should be solid I think.

Also, note this isn't a walkthrough per se, as sometimes taking a lose can lead to future, better gains.

Edit: Small mod update, added a note for score goal during Week 1 interview.
Edit 2: Small bug fix for round 2 of week 1 exhibition.
There is a small typo in extras.rpy, line 268 (open with proper texteditor like Notepad++ on windows), generating an error for me when opening the jukebox in the leisure room.

replace this line:
Python:
textbutton "Thunder by Delicate Steve" action mr.Play("music/music/thunder.mp3")
with:
Python:
textbutton "Thunder by Delicate Steve" action mr.Play("music/thunder.mp3")
Or replace extras.rpa in game folder, after installing PaleCarnations-Ch3Up1-InGameMod.zip by seigram, with the extras.rpy in the attached zip file.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TD1900

IndigoHawk

Member
Aug 9, 2016
157
577
Veronica and Hana are top tier in my opinion. Strong and interesting. Gaining their respect/affection is worth the effort. Maybe Felicia too, but she's still an enigma.

Mina seems a bit dumb (maybe just really sheltered I guess), but she's ok. I like that Hana wants to bully her a bit.

Rosalind ... I'm not sure there's much that can be done to make her more appealing. She's attractive but kind of mousy so gets overshadowed.

Maybe there could be a flamethrower route. Feels like the game could use an old school porn ending where the den of iniquity is destroyed, even if it's not canonical. MC teams up with a couple of the girls and burns that place down!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RC-1138 Boss

Aleatory

Newbie
Jun 22, 2017
49
100
Rosalind ... I'm not sure there's much that can be done to make her more appealing. She's attractive but kind of mousy so gets overshadowed.
I actually see lots of potential in her story. Especially the comparisons that could be drawn with Rosalind's and Victoria's situation could become pretty interesting and/or morally challenging for MC.

(just thoughts about Rosalinds story so far in spoilers)
I think, for example, that MC is in turmoil with himself trying to figure out if he wants to help Rosalind to not have to do the things his mother did to get by... or to satisfy his own carnal desires.

I personally find that thought pretty interesting! Although, I feel the need to reiterate that the other characters defintely have things going for them in their storyline as well; all of them are just really good!
 
Nov 23, 2020
299
302
I love this work made me fall in love with these characters knowing they are risking it all for personal game through sex work. That is the sad part which I found is that you actually fall for these women knowing the environment. An example is Rosalind which is like a throwback to the MC's Mom who had no one to lookout for her while we are looking out for her (Rosalind fans). Not shitting on the sex work industry, but under kathleen you just know that even with graduating, these girls will have a rough time with sadistic and weird sex clients especially when you come to love some of these ambitious women. I'm ready to have a pensive moment haha Keep up the good work.
 

MoarDakka123

Active Member
Jul 7, 2020
926
1,237
... Huh.

I just realized you see someone who looks a lot like Dalia when you start up the game; three pictures of what I presume are previous Carnations.

EDIT Nevermind, Dalia's mole is below her lips on her left side and does not have green eyes. Would've been a nice little window into her backstory, though.

1620335808857.png
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AwsHen

TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
786
7,231
... Huh.

I just realized you see someone who looks a lot like Dalia when you start up the game; three pictures of what I presume are previous Carnations.

View attachment 1182088

EDIT Nevermind, Dalia's mole is below her lips and does not have green eyes. Would've been a nice little window into her backstory, though.
There is a familiar face among them. ;)
 

MoarDakka123

Active Member
Jul 7, 2020
926
1,237
There is a familiar face among them. ;)
Whelp, I'm just going to assume you don't mean Warren.

That in mind... I found a redhead, but her eye colour doesn't match. I present to you, exhibit A.

1620342478222.png

HOWEVER!

In exhibit B, we find out she has a mole, and coupled with her green eyes, I do believe this now-redhead is the not-Dalia from my previous post.

1620343454199.png


EDIT
... Fuck, it's already 2:30.
 
4.90 star(s) 498 Votes