VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[ename144]

I am really curious how pic and text fit together. While most likely Mina is talking about another girl with the unknown caller, there are further options.

The easiest explanation is that Mina's talking to the MC about Hana. She knows they're coworkers, the MC knows a few details of Hana's life that might provoke such a response, and Mina won't know the two are anything more than coworkers unless you ended Mina's path to stay faithful to Hana.

She could also be talking to Hana, though that seems more of a stretch since Mina doesn't know any of Hana's female coworkers. I suppose it's possible Hana might be looking to talk about something one of the house girls shared about their private lives, but it's hard to see how such a conversation could last more than a sentence without getting into territory best kept secret.

 

[ffive]

She could also be talking to Hana, though that seems more of a stretch since Mina doesn't know any of Hana's female coworkers.

Could be something like Mina asking Hana about older woman staying at MC's place and Hana making up stuff about Rose being a co-worker to avoid having to reveal details of the "work". But talking to MC about Hana is a simpler explanation here, so i'd go with that.

 

[Machete]

I am sorry to tell you this will stay a wish. TD, the writer of Pale Carnations, already told us that the MC´s Mom is more of a moral compass and story element. For the MC, her sacrifices years ago to keep them fed is a major drive for several things he does and admires.

Which is for the best. This is a story oriented game and bang the mommy would sink the overall quality of the plot. Rosalind is already the bang mommy experience.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

Hana doesn't make any sense, as we've seen her closest confidants are people OUTSIDE the club like her bandmates and friends, and she's specfiically (and correctly) suspicious of those inside the club.

 

[DarkLords00]

Hana doesn't make any sense, as we've seen her closest confidants are people OUTSIDE the club like her bandmates and friends, and she's specfiically (and correctly) suspicious of those inside the club.

I mean, Mina doesn't know this and after they hanged out with Hana and how vague and evasive everyone she knows work there talk about said gig. I would be very surprised if Mina doesn't already suspect Hana, Edwin and Killian are involved in something shady but chooses to not poke around so much either due to respect their (Hana and Edwin) wish for privacy/secrecy or because she is afraid of what she might find out if she pokes around too much.

I would assume after Hana called her out seemingly out of nowhere saying she wanted to hang out with someone not work related and she didn't give any more explanations about what happaned other than a very shitty work day, she probably is righteously worried about her and is asking Edwin to check on her.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

I mean, Mina doesn't know this and after they hanged out with Hana and how vague and evasive everyone she knows work there talk about said gig. I would be very surprised if Mina doesn't already suspect Hana, Edwin and Killian are involved in something shady but chooses to not poke around so much either due to respect their (Hana and Edwin) wish for privacy/secrecy or because she is afraid of what she might find out if she pokes around too much.

I would assume after Hana called her out seemingly out of nowhere saying she wanted to hang out with someone not work related and she didn't give any more explanations about what happaned other than a very shitty work day, she probably is righteously worried about her and is asking Edwin to check on her.

No, but she says the opposite - the line above is " must be serious if she only has a co-worker to turn to"

 

[Machete]

Hana doesn't make any sense, as we've seen her closest confidants are people OUTSIDE the club like her bandmates and friends, and she's specfiically (and correctly) suspicious of those inside the club.

Hana, i believe, is supposed to be a girl looking for her true self. She didn't archieve much in her life and she must be thinking that to be a pimp or worst as her father is her only option in life, while wishing she could have something different completely.

At last it's the impression the character gave me.

I believe one of the possible arcs for MC and Hana would be to find a way to leave the club behind.

 

[Idontplay]

Could be something like Mina asking Hana about older woman staying at MC's place and Hana making up stuff about Rose being a co-worker to avoid having to reveal details of the "work". But talking to MC about Hana is a simpler explanation here, so i'd go with that.

It could be something like:
«Hi Hana! Yesterday I had a threesome wiith Edwin and Felicia and…»
«WHAAAAAAT?!»

 

[reeroll]

I am sorry to tell you this will stay a wish. TD, the writer of Pale Carnations, already told us that the MC´s Mom is more of a moral compass and story element. For the MC, her sacrifices years ago to keep them fed is a major drive for several things he does and admires.

i know that's why i am sad... kinda a waste to be honest.what makes it worse it will never happen aside if they create an incest patch version on subscribestar

 

[ffive]

i know that's why i am sad... kinda a waste to be honest.what makes it worse it will never happen aside if they create an incest patch version on subscribestar

Honestly, it's one of few things which set this title apart from the slop of your average incest games, so it's not a waste but a solid decision.

 

[reeroll]

Honestly, it's one of few things which set this title apart from the slop of your average incest games, so it's not a waste but a solid decision.

i don't share that opinion but that's ok too.everyone is entitled to their own opinions.

 

[yanjiejiu]

i haven't finished Mina content so maybe this was updates ago - but this is now replaced by a certain blonde


I love details as such

 

[NukaCola]

Hi. I hasn't play since Chap 4 up 3. Can someone tell me if there is new Mina content in ch4up4 ? I looks at the gallery and there is one new scene with both Mina and Fellicia. But is that the only one? No other Mina scene?

 

[Ass prefer]

Hi. I hasn't play since Chap 4 up 3. Can someone tell me if there is new Mina content in ch4up4 ? I looks at the gallery and there is one new scene with both Mina and Fellicia. But is that the only one? No other Mina scene?

Only one.

 

[helo138]

Only one.

But what a scene it is

 

[Idontplay]

I think we can say it is a loooooong juuuuuuiiiiicy threesome.

 

[Ottoeight]

Hi. I hasn't play since Chap 4 up 3. Can someone tell me if there is new Mina content in ch4up4 ? I looks at the gallery and there is one new scene with both Mina and Fellicia. But is that the only one? No other Mina scene?

It's NOT "a scene". It's a whole event.

 

[Ottoeight]

i haven't finished Mina content so maybe this was updates ago - but this is now replaced by a certain blonde
View attachment 3925584

I love details as such

We might see a new framed picture on that wall next to it: Edwin, Mina & Hana. Together.

 

[ffive]

We might see a new framed picture on that wall next to it: Edwin, Mina & Hana. Together.

After her most recent experience with boyfriends Mina will probably hold off on hanging pictures of her crushes, at least for a while.

 

[Nice Guy Eddie]

I strongly doubt that, the game would be over already

I bet the info you catched was 4 weeks (in game) since that's ho long the carnations contest is supposed to last. No, i don't remember if the game is in the 2nd or 3rd week of the contest. I think the second, since the 3rd week of the previous year's contest was a 'free use' day. Which i'm positive won't happen in this edition of the contest. You know.. NTR... but i think i'd noticed it didn't happen.

Now, not sure what the plan for the plot are. Maybe the contest will be interrupted before the 4th week in the climax event that crushes the bordello activity once and for all or it will just go through and something will happen later.

In any case i'm positive we will see at the very least Chapter 5. Not impossible a Chapter 6. And let's hope M&J won't go full BaDIK an pull out some bullshit like 'and that was season 1, for season 2 we have...' Spin offs are cool, endless games aren't.

thank you! i ve lost track indeed. played the game like a year ago or so and lost my saves so i wanted to wait the game is finished to start all over again... but i think i should catch up !

and yeah i totally agree with you. it's important to be able to complete a story and a game overall. and it's so very rare !