VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

4.80 star(s) 536 Votes
Discussion Reviews (536)
D

Deleted member 5730975

Member
Jan 21, 2023
196
607
Turret said:
Wow, somebody has a hate boner for "Quadtails" it seems. ;) And I am not even that much of a Mina fan, Hana, Felicia and Sophia for the win!:)(y)
Click to expand...
I actually like mina quite a lot. Like a lot of people she and Hana are my favorite girls in the game. Mindbreaking the innocent girl is a classic hentai trope and I just happen to like that particular trope.

I have two saves one where Edwin tries to remain a decent person and the other where he acts like a psychopath.

I want all the girls mindbroken in the second save. Top of the list is mina followed by felicia. I think Hana is the only girl I dont really want to see completely mindbroken simply because it might not fit the story very well given she is an owner of the club. I see her being exactly like Kat in the future in the save where Edwin is a psychopath. But that said she has masochistic tendencies so maybe she can be mindbroken too.
 
  • Thinking Face
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Gab1, JasonsGranpa, Zerorox and 1 other person
Zerorox

Zerorox

Active Member
Dec 5, 2021
690
1,120
lt1940 said:
I actually like mina quite a lot. Like a lot of people she and Hana are my favorite girls in the game. Mindbreaking the innocent girl is a classic hentai trope and I just happen to like that particular trope.

I have two saves one where Edwin tries to remain a decent person and the other where he acts like a psychopath.

I want all the girls mindbroken in the second save. Top of the list is mina followed by felicia. I think Hana is the only girl I dont really want to see completely mindbroken simply because it might not fit the story very well given she is an owner of the club. I see her being exactly like Kat in the future in the save where Edwin is a psychopath. But that said she has masochistic tendencies so maybe she can be mindbroken too.
Click to expand...
Nah, there are no totally innocent girls here, Mina is Just like to playin' "cute bunny"
I'm not sayin' she's depraved slut, but she is avg/normal young woman exploring her fetishes so... I don't think that Hentai trope Will work here
Edwin corruption is main theme, other characters had no great changes in their personality (yet?), Just partly lifted their masks IMO
And I'm not sure 'bout mind broken thing also, women minds are not that fragile here as it's shown in some hentai
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Gab1, Ragnar and bo77om
D

Deleted member 5730975

Member
Jan 21, 2023
196
607
Zerorox said:
Nah, there are no totally innocent girls here, Mina is Just like to playin' "cute bunny"
I'm not sayin' she's depraved slut, but she is avg/normal young woman exploring her fetishes so... I don't think that Hentai trope Will work here
Edwin corruption is main theme, other characters had no great changes in their personality (yet?), Just partly lifted their masks IMO
And I'm not sure 'bout mind broken thing also, women minds are not that fragile here as it's shown in some hentai
Click to expand...
My psychopath Edwin wants to give her a bit more than what she had bargained for when she tells him that she wants to explore her fetishes.

As for the mindbreaking - you are forgetting about Abel and Sophia's magical sex drugs. Although it is true that we dont know what they really do to someone who uses them.
 
D

Deleted member 5730975

Member
Jan 21, 2023
196
607
Turret said:
Since some time has passed since the last tiermaking, here is my current one. Discussion is open!:)
View attachment 2629365
Click to expand...
I like the out of order tiers.

Also kat too low. She makes the evil Edwin route for me and that route would be a lot worse without her. She is the evil equivalent to what Hana is in my vanilla/nice guy save. Sophia would be a B tier for me because she has not had screen time yet but she shows the most potential to go up the tiers in future updates. Everything else I agree with (I would bump mina up to A and Felicia down to A though)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Turret and True_Degenerate
J

JasonsGranpa

Member
Apr 30, 2023
214
209
Turret said:
Since some time has passed since the last tiermaking, here is my current one. Discussion is open!:)
View attachment 2629365
Click to expand...

LET THE FLAME WARS BEGIN!!

i saw your updated list, but i always think tierlists without explanation are not very informative.

does it represent the interest to get dick polished? want to marry? want to have as a personal pet? etc.

i really like tierlists with more glimpses into the persons mind (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turret
T

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,503
7,722
JasonsGranpa said:
LET THE FLAME WARS BEGIN!!
i saw your updated list, but i always think tierlists without explanation are not very informative.
does it represent the interest to get dick polished? want to marry? want to have as a personal pet? etc.
i really like tierlists with more glimpses into the persons mind (y)
Click to expand...
No problem, here are a few tidbits more about my current ranking! This list is ranked towards both "getting your dick polished";) and "who to marry":). I incorporated looks and personality (as far as we know now) into the list, which is one reason why the bottom is where they are. Kath might be personalitywise worse than the others, but she is an important character and for all her flaws she is hardly as annoying as the bottom.
Frak, even Kath and Harper have a better result in mothering than Ian´s "Mom" has. His parents are the main reason he is who he is. Vicki was more a mom for Ian than Grace ever was. How Jerrica "introduced" herself was enough for me. She might be a nice girl, but currently we have not seen much of it.

An "evilknivel":D list would look different, with e.g. Kath a lot higher in rank.
 
  • Heart
Reactions: JasonsGranpa
J

JasonsGranpa

Member
Apr 30, 2023
214
209
Marry/(or as a Mom):

S -
A -
B -
C -
D -
F - All

(there are differences, but when i think of a girl good enough to marry, all are utter horror. even hana.)


Getting dick polished/personal pet:

S - All*
A -
B -
C -
D -
F - *pink haired chick (not touching that one *shudder*)

(if i'd ever met a girl with the body and face of a honey select model i'd surely not said no*. hot af. even when 50yo lol. with smaller tits S+++ tier kek)



Turret said:
No problem, here are a few tidbits more about my current ranking! This list is ranked towards both "getting your dick polished";) and "who to marry":). I incorporated looks and personality (as far as we know now) into the list, which is one reason why the bottom is where they are. Kath might be personalitywise worse than the others, but she is an important character and for all her flaws she is hardly as annoying as the bottom.
Frak, even Kath and Harper have a better result in mothering than Ian´s "Mom" has. His parents are the main reason he is who he is. Vicki was more a mom for Ian than Grace ever was. How Jerrica "introduced" herself was enough for me. She might be a nice girl, but currently we have not seen much of it.

An "evilknivel":D list would look different, with e.g. Kath a lot higher in rank.
Click to expand...
 
  • Heart
Reactions: Turret
T

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,503
7,722
JasonsGranpa said:
Marry/(or as a Mom):

S -
A -
B -
C -
D -
F - All

(there are differences, but when i think of a girl good enough to marry, all are utter horror. even hana.)


Getting dick polished/personal pet:

S - All*
A -
B -
C -
D -
F - *pink haired chick (not touching that one *shudder*)

(if i'd ever met a girl with the body and face of a honey select model i'd surely not said no*. hot af. even when 50yo lol. with smaller tits S+++ tier kek)
Click to expand...
An interesting list by you! I see it a bit differently, but I respect your opinion very much. I´d like to know why you consider all girls of PC as "utter horror" towards marriage? For some, that is absolutely true, but others not so much.
I had to grin at your placement of Jerrica. It seems she made a similar expression on us when she popped up first. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JasonsGranpa
M

misfolk

Active Member
Jan 22, 2021
934
1,435
Turret said:
An interesting list by you! I see it a bit differently, but I respect your opinion very much. I´d like to know why you consider all girls of PC as "utter horror" towards marriage?
Click to expand...
Let me try:
Rosalind has poor taste in men. She'll leave me for the next loser.
Victoria has already sacrificed one marriage in the name of her business.
Felicia is a self-proclaimed gold digger. She'll dump me for some sugar daddy.
Katherine is a manipulative sociopathic hag.
Sophia is a psychopath.
Mina has even worse taste in men than Rosalind. I can cut her some slack for being young and inexperienced, but what if her bad boy addiction is incurable?
Hana is fine, even if I don't like the tattoos. It's the in-laws that are the problem.
 
  • Like
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: OdinValgallovih, JasonsGranpa and GIL3D
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.80 star(s) 536 Votes