slightchance

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2018
1,229
2,527
466
This sounds like invested fanfiction, but you'll likely need to find a game with NTR tag to see them fulfilled to some extent.
The scenario I'm thinking about goes more in the direction of NTS, swinging, voyeurism and sharing. It's not like Edwin is the only one in this game laying pipe or is he?
 

Idontplay

Well-Known Member
Oct 30, 2017
1,607
2,255
488
This is the dumbest argument in the entire world. You know what the odds are that the whole town found out about Victoria's porn career? It's exactly 0%. ZERO PERCENT, because it didn't happen. The dev makes the universe, and in this universe it didn't happen. Period. All opinions are meaningless.
Well actually someone has find out that (Ian's mother), but if the average player would actually read the dialogues, he would find out that nobody went to Edwin saying: «Your mother was a pornstar!» or went to Victoria saying: «I know you were a pornstar!»; except for Grace. So yes, it is the dumbest argument, because the "Pale Carnation-verse" is created by the developers and they will address this issue when and if it will be meaningful for the story (Grace's revelation again), not because we start to debate about it.

What are the chances that Hana will enjoy some activities with other men if Edwin opens up a voyeuristic path?
There are chances that Edwin will become a voyeur?
 
Last edited:
  • Yay, update!
Reactions: Maccabbee

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
9,769
24,192
812
The scenario I'm thinking about goes more in the direction of NTS, swinging, voyeurism and sharing. It's not like Edwin is the only one in this game laying pipe or is he?
I realize, but there's no netorase tag, so those games tend to be marked with NTR one. You will note that this game has no sharing nor NTR in its description. And voyeurism is basically limited to watching MC's mother (who is not a RO) porn flicks. So this is simply not the sort of content you're likely to find in this game. Regardless of how many men in it have dicks.

The closest i can think of is an option to have Ian instead of Edwin fuck Rose on stage, for the purpose of the show. And a few threesomes you can have with him.
 

slightchance

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2018
1,229
2,527
466
You will note that this game has no sharing nor NTR in its description. And voyeurism is basically limited to watching MC's mother (who is not a RO) porn flicks. So this is simply not the sort of content you're likely to find in this game. Regardless of how many men in it have dicks.

The closest i can think of is an option to have Ian instead of Edwin fuck Rose on stage, for the purpose of the show. And a few threesomes you can have with him.
I think you forgot a few other scenes. Ian has sex with his nanny while Edwin is on the phone and both can share one of the carnations, on top of all the other prostitutes in the club getting dicked left and right.

It's a bit unrealistic that neither Hana nor Mina won't ever be involved in any other activities, given the circumstances, but I guess this is where the devs could draw the line. I'm well aware of that. It's just that they could write Hana like that if they wanted to, it would still fit the overall tone of the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spirox

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
9,769
24,192
812
and both can share one of the carnations
I did include "and a few threesomes you can have with him" in my post. That's one of them. Another is Edwin and Ian having threesome with Felicia early in the game. And yet another is Edwin's threesome with Mina and Felicia, where you can opt to sit in the cuck chair for a bit. I guess if you really stretch it, then Edwin can also influence Mina to get involved with Veronica, which you could also consider some sort of sharing (depending on whether you subscribe to "if it's with another girl then it doesn't count" or not)

However, those are in circumstances where Edwin's relationship with the involved girl(s) is at best casual. I dunno, this game just doesn't strike me as one where this would be any sort of in-depth interest in exploring this area in combination with dedicated relationships.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Biscardone

Henchmen13

New Member
Feb 14, 2023
11
6
126
Given that this is the beginning of the update, i think it's Edwin on the phone with Kath before the exhibition. Do you guys think she sends him on do some preparations?
 

Henchmen13

New Member
Feb 14, 2023
11
6
126
Is it her guy Warren? He called her Mrs.P
Good point, maybe there is some situation. Give the Rosie situation and how it happened two times, i am honestly expecting the loan shark to show up third time. Another think that comes to mind is that Waren was informed about Edwin digging info about Ian's friend, after all he is paid by the club and Mrs P on top of that
 

Thor875

Newbie
Jan 8, 2019
56
30
161
Chapter 4 Up 6 Preview (1)

"Ahem Hey, Mrs. P..."
Chapter 4 Up 6 Preview (1)
The clothing looks rather serious and it seems to be some kind of briefcase. The whole thing looks like a wardrobe for travelling. Eden Women's Relief Fund, is she already looking for carnations for next season?
 
Last edited:

Darreau91

Formerly 'DarreuRR'
Dec 31, 2022
264
1,026
266
Given that this is the beginning of the update, i think it's Edwin on the phone with Kath before the exhibition. Do you guys think she sends him on do some preparations?
My imagination has Kathleen inviting Edwin over to her place to get him in the right mindset for exhibition. To get him wound up she puts on a Vicky porn video. She trash talks him for a bit while being suggestive. Then she injects him with the horny medicine while Edwin is flustered/pissed off. Kathleen proceeds to ride and peg the shit out of Edwin. All this with the porn video still playing in the background and… Kathleen’s husband watching through a peep hole in the next room.
 

Henchmen13

New Member
Feb 14, 2023
11
6
126
Question: How many of the community here took the decision to cross the line with Mina?
I did on my original playtroughs, it's shaping to be clusterfuck when it comes to choices BUT i am hoping for Mina GF but the end of the game.
Also most people have multiple saves, same as me, so in theory everyone has.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
5,082
8,773
786
View attachment 4510029
Chapter 4 Up 6 Preview (1)

"Ahem Hey, Mrs. P..."
Somehow I doubt that it is Edwin calling Kathleen here. Possible, but unprobable. Warren usually calls Kath Mrs.P, so it is with a good chance him. The topic of this call is another secret for now.

Good point, maybe there is some situation. Give the Rosie situation and how it happened two times, i am honestly expecting the loan shark to show up third time. Another think that comes to mind is that Waren was informed about Edwin digging info about Ian's friend, after all he is paid by the club and Mrs P on top of that
The loan shark is only a problem if you "solve" this problem with Kath or Chuck/Killian. If you get August (you need a high friendship score) solving the "just Oliver" problem, he will never make problems for Rosi again. In this case Oliver was most likely killed or if still alive, will not be in any kind of position to threaten Rosi or the others. Remember, what happened to OIiver will make it into the news! He is/was definitely a stupid guy. August made him "an offer he couldn´t refuse", but Oliver did refuse.
You second theory sounds interesting and could be the reason for the call.

View attachment 4484780
Bonus Art: Pick Your Poison

This will become a transition screen next update.
I like the wordplay here. Both women have their own pitfalls and are rivals and circumstantial allies. Should a situation like tihsarise, my Edwins would loose quite a number of points with Kath, since I vastly prefer Sophia over her.
 
4.80 star(s) 554 Votes