- Sep 30, 2017
- 2,362
- 4,933
Throwing some spanners in the works. Of course, no one's top list will be the same...Completely agree, what makes something the best? GOAT acronym for example is a term/acronym I always avoid to use (maybe can use GOATIMHO lol), it always comes to each one taste, each one generation (I'm Portuguese and love Football and i'm near 50 yo, I would say Eusébio is the Goat, if I was younger probably CR7, if i was Argentinian Maradona or Messi etc etc), lot of variables to say what or who is the best or greatest.
If you look at my sig it is just my opinion on my favorite/best games and I really can't say which one I prefer the most, maybe if vote was on categories probably would work for example:
- Best comedy (Projekt Passion without a doubt)
- Best soundtracks minigames and free roams (BaDIK)
- Best Animations (probably Eternum, some of them are very crazy but all of them are very good in that aspect)
- Best story and character building (all of them are very good, don't make me chose lol)
- Best HS1 game "that even make some HS2 game jealous" lol (Ripples)
- Best "game world building" (imo The Seven Realms, name says all lol)
- Best sci-fi "cyberpunk" story and ambiance (City of Broken dreamers)
Joking around a bit in those categories but was just to prove a point, I really can't say which of those 6 I prefer above the other 5. Wish I could by the rules to put a gif/sig of each of those games in my signature hehe but limit is 2 so once in a while when in the mood I change them.
But I do think one can talk about a GOAT game for sure.
For instance, I think it's Almost Universally agreed on that Project Passion, BADIK, Eternum are considered to be amongst the best on F95.
For me for instance, BADIK stands head and shoulders above pretty much any other game on F95. In terms of Production value, content, storytelling soundtracks minigames etc. etc.
Sure, sure I agree with you, Project Passion has BIDIK beat when it comes to comedy, but in the end of the day one can award an Oscar for best Movie, even though it is not the best Comedy.
I can list my top 10 games and for myself I cannot choose between them. but I can still objectively agree that even though I enjoy say Project passion more, gameA could be considered the GOAT.
BTW. Some other GOAT worthy mentions:
Pale Carnations, Leap Of Faith, Hillside