Yeah, same. Maggie is great too, but Allie just has that extra something. And I'm sure it's been said a few times that it was all MC's fault, I think he slept around, maybe?
It's a weird one, because Allie has one great lewd scene, but because it's basically a hate fuck, it's a path that I don't want to be on. So I've played it and will continue it just to see where it goes, but my main save is going on a long run after Allie. I don't mind waiting for her (and until it causes a problem, I have Jasmine and Maggie on the side anyway).