I wonder if it plays out differently depending on the conversations prior?Look through all the script (I can't check myself right now unfortunately, not at my pc). IIRC there is a choice before this scene...and on one of them....she gave him nothing for years, no affection at all.
Now..if this has been changed quietly by the dev....
I always take a more "adult" and reconciliatory approach to Allie, if not not pursuing her LI path.
Although that would definitely play into how differently we see the story.