I guess I should have said it has the potential to be head and shoulders above...Yes, and until they release this pending update and show that they can release on a consistent schedule, with consistent communication, I don't see the pressure letting up soon.
The fact that all developers are judged because of the actions of a few is one of the most frustrating parts of this community/game genre. I am not saying that criticism isn't warranted but the idea that every dev who misses a deadline is immediately accused of milking or compared to the more egregious developers is frustrating. Especially considering the year we are all experiencing.
I am glad you are so confident about the update. I am not as optimistic about the content or length of what comes next. Especially when it means we get two updates this year and, for all we know, every year. In my opinion it is too early to say this game is better than most game on F95 considering we've had exactly one release. There are some absolutely great games on this site and Radiant, though it had a promising start, needs more content before it will dethrone those games.
Overall, though I am still very interested to see what is coming up with this game, the fact that two experienced developers can't release more than one update this year makes me skeptical that we shall see consistent releases afterwards. As someone who has defended them, and received plenty of facepalms for it, I am starting to be worn out with the waiting and silence.
And, yeah, I'm right there with you. Part of the problem in this community is that people tend to mash together everyone with criticisms or with support. There are lots of idiots who jump in 2 weeks after a game's dropped to go "whens update" which becomes "there milking!" 2 weeks later. That's not the same as someone 5 months later going "this shouldn't be taking this long". The flip side is that there are people who constantly fluff the dev going "take all the time you need" no matter how long it's been or how transparently a dev has lied. That's not the same as someone telling one of the "there milking" dipshits to shut the fuck up when the dev has been fairly open about progress.
Personally, my confidence in this took a hit with Alorth's discord post about his personal issues. I've been through that, so I totally feel for him, but while that was apparently going on they were telling their supporters that everything was going fine, with no hint that they had hit a major speedbump.
Anyway, I'll wait about 2 more weeks to see if the update drops, and if it does I'll wait about 2 more weeks to see if they address the future timeline.