I see it another way: there is no better or worse, old and new scenes just different. I guess no one will argue that in adult games, what characters wear - means a lot, so, since usually you changing clothes in redone scenes, those old scenes would feel like new scenes for a player who didn't see them. Especially since those older clothes, at least for Adrianna, even if being misplaced, was more fetish, with all those tights and short dresses with deep necklines.
If RHC were not a VN, it would be good idea to make these alternative scenes unlockable by fulfilling some hard conditions or winning it in gacha machines.