This is such a difficult game to rate. I've been playing it on and off since one of the earlier releases and the biggest problem i see with the project is that it seems aimless.
The smut, H-scenes and the writing are top notch. Yes, there are some scenes with just a black screen, but how everything is written is so good that you can imagine the scene in your head. One thing i love about this game, and i think more games should do is create a barrier between the player and the MCs.
Because yes, for me both Rowan and Alexia are the MCs, specially because you make decisions with both characters. This situation and the idea that they are characters and not you create a possibility to just go crazy and put then in the more perverse situations possible just to have fun. Playing this game i don't feel like i'm Rowan or Alexia, i'm the director of a porn movie or something like that.
Like i said, more games should replicate that, it's very fun. For me the problem with this game is the gameplay and how aimless it feels. The sex scenes outside of the keep are so boring and the entire progression of the story, tied with the possibility of game overs if you don't progress enough is really grating.
This is absolutely a game that needs a Walkthrough, specially because you may miss a scene you may want, or even get a scene you don't want because the choices just aren't well enough explained. This sometimes can feel like a violation of trust between you and the game. Thankfully, save scumming is always possible and necessary here to prevent headaches.
The dev team needs to focus on two things to make this a masterpiece. Some quality of life additions to the UI and gameplay, more focus the main story to make it more engaging than the keep moments. The main problem is that they seem to be harmstrung by a mix of big ideas with not enough resources to make them possible and since they are trying to please every possibility, fetish and perversion imaginable, it's difficult to make drastic changes to the game and progress the story in an unexpected way.
So it's really good, if you can overcome theses problems. But they weight a lot and make this game not for everyone. The real rate would be a 3.5, but since you can't do that, i'm gonna rate up because i do have a lot of affection for this game, and i hope the dev team can find some focus, take this game in a great direction and all the way to the finishing line. So temper your expectations.
PS: Can we have some way to take Alexia away from the keep? Her scenes are great but because of being a prisoner it's starting to get repetitive.