Shirou x Irisviel OTP
Member
- Oct 8, 2021
- 285
- 472
- 90
Lilia has grown on me, but I also prefer Rabiane. I will only add two comments.1-> S1 only has 3 pregnancies, they're all nice but aside from the last boss, quite simple scenes. S2 just mogs it with the pregnant condition that can be used on all animations, and the more elaborate pregnancy events. It's a no brainer.
2-> S1 has a better cathedral slavery sequence, period. When it comes to the farm and village, S2 one-up'd them easily, and then added the demi-human and village events on top. Hard to compete.
3-> This is tricky. In a vacuum, the guro is more evenly distributed in the sequel, whereas the first game frontloaded it. The sequel also often mixes guro into its sex scenes, instead of being one or the other. As someone who dislikes guro, I prefer the sequel because at least there is no "full-on guro level" anymore. Someone who likes guro might prefer the first game.
4-> The first game has a more oppressive atmosphere due to its pixel art visuals and very dark levels, but also the utter lack of dialogue and support characters. It was also harder. S1 has S2 beaten there.
5-> S2 has a couple of nothing levels (like the mushroom road) or ones that are kinda too bare-bone (leech swamp). It also dumps a bunch of bosses and content (boss zombie, boss tree, boss floating parasite) on the highway instead of giving them proper levels. I would say overall, despite the improvements to gameplay and some ambitious levels in S2, S1's levels are better put together on average.
6-> A significant amount of bosses in S2 get pulverized with magic unless you're missing a bunch of upgrades. It's a tough call, because some bosses there are great. Still, bosses were usually the highlight of a level sex scene-wise in S1, and in S2 a bunch of them have pretty underwhelming defeat events. I'm leaning toward S1 winning that category.
That's 3 win for both - but those 6 categories aside, I would say S2 is easily the better game, still. By virtue of having better gameplay, visuals and a... smoother one handed experience. It's an impressive step up for the game dev.
I still prefer Rabiane over Lilia!
View attachment 4753150
1. You are missing one more pregnancy in Sinisistar 1: Slug Boss, Pig Boss, the Observer, and the worms that have human-like torsos in the lab.
2. I agree with the village level being more complete in the second game, but the chase is better done in Sinisistar 1 since you cannot kill all the parasited villagers coming at you, and this forces you to jump towards the boss fight.... still, two boss fights give the second game an edge. The Pig Man Boss fight is challenging in the second game, and the defeat scenes are better; however, Sinisistar 1 had more enemies working as obstacles and two boss fights in its Farm Level (the sack of worms and, then the Giant Pig).