Huh. Interesting, guess I'll see some details when I do a corrupted playthrough eventually. Not gonna be too soon though, I need a break from this game. XD
As for Dolus, I honestly don't have any sympathy for him. He had
1000 years to do basically anything, during which time he was essentially invincible because no one could realistically stop him and his bullshit... and he achieved nothing in that time except for creating misogynistic traditions in the Demon Cult and the whole
Maid Academy bullshit. He's by far the biggest fuck-up in the whole game.
Ooof.
The amusing thing is early Aura shows that none of this should really apply to her. She isn't the type to settle with "nothing can be done", and she immediately suspect Luciela is Aura within the first few days. I at the very least expected the corruption route to go down the "the reason Aura reconnects with Alica is to check whether she is Luciela" trope (and how she does that is coloured by the corruption), while I wanted "if Aura is uncorrupted, she also decides to investigate it, but differently."
Aura just... not connecting with her friends at all anymore if she is uncorrupted and not doing a two pronged assault is just such a missed opportunity, but I can see how that decision ended up being made.
If the core conceit of the show is "see how the corruption produces cascading changes" rather than "see how Aura deals with the corruption colouring her actions", well. It's very disappointing, but, once again there is no unlimited dev time, and it's important to keep close to a core if you ever want to finish a well done game.
There is imo such a ludonarrative dissonance between the Royan set up of Aura always needing to be careful about people constantly trying to catch her, her immediately noticing a lot of it, and trying to do the best she can about it, and "but for earth, huh, the gameplay is all about /not/ taking the Royan gameplay seriously", however.
While to an extent, I get where you're coming from, realistically, Aura simply has hard limits to what she can actually do on Earth. Also, as said before, she doesn't believe that the stuff on Earth is important. There's no magic on Earth and there's no direct connection between the actions on Earth and the actions in Roya. Not to mention that, as established during the prologue, killing Richard on Earth would just ensure that he's the Demon Lord full time in Roya and solves absolutely nothing. The same applies to Luciela. Even if she absolutely proved somehow that Alicia was Luciela, it wouldn't really change much... at least in her mind.
It's also established from the get-go that Aura is... quite frankly... a bit of an arrogant idiot. Her subconscious self exemplifies this clearly when she meets Alicia. For all that she's book-smart, she's not actually all that smart in the people sense. The idea of gradual, seemingly insignificant changes to her mind feeding into major changes which then feed into the complete alteration of her self
doesn't occur to her at all. Even though that's really the first thing that she should have thought of.
In general, Aura exhibits a tendency of being
really stupid about some things...
Which is... tbh... fairly consistent with a teenager. They're often dumber than they think they are and this definitely applies to Aura. If she was actually as smart as she thought she was, there would have been plenty of ways for her to foil various parts of Richard's plan from the prologue itself. I mean really... not even suspecting a trap and walking face-first into it was amazingly dumb... Accepting that split-up was also amazingly dumb. If she played things smart during the prologue, odds are that she could have saved at least George, leaving her with one full powered companion even if everything else went the same, which would have changed the equation completely.
If/when you do a corruption playthrough, or just add in corruption as you push towards murderizing Richard in Roya, you'll see that as the mental changes pile up, Aura gets confronted about said changes at certain points, and she completely dismisses the possibility that those changes are in any way related to the Curse. In her mind, the Curse and its changes are only linked to Roya, not Earth, and the idea that Luciela might be spending her time to turn her into a monster on Earth specifically, or where that might lead, just doesn't click.
As for her friends on Earth... I can get why Aura didn't involve Rose, after all, she didn't have anything to really prove her experiences in Roya. However, she DID have something for George, because George tells her something in the prologue that he never did on Earth, and talking to him about it would have been fairly solid proof that something fucked up happened. That said, she didn't want to worry him about it all when he was so busy with his family, and when he was powerless to do anything from Earth while she kept going to Roya every night. It's a reasonable impulse tbh... but obviously stupid given the circumstances.