[ up to 0.6.1 ep2 ]
Story: 3/5 : 5/5 for premise, 4/5 for dialogues, 1/5 for sheer walls of it
Graphics: backgrounds 5/5, characters 3/5 (ep1), 4/5 (ep2)
Sex scenes: 0/5 -- yes. There are a like 3-5 sex scenes over the whole game so far, but the rating stays. More on it below.
Maledom: 0,5/5 (I have decided to put this in my reviews from now on, since I am almost only playing and reviewing games with this type of tag)
Summary: A not-a-porn-game porn game AVN. If you'd expect to fap at this, you'd be sorely disappointed or have a really strong imagination or very specific fetish that involves getting aroused enough from simply talking (mostly about power, not sex). I give the game a total of 3/5 because the story premise is good, but the execution is mostly overly winded.
Should be tagged kinetic novel by Ep2. There are about 1-2 choices in Ep1, but they don't seem to lead to any changes in plot.
Background:
So we have a twist take on what is very loosely based on the Lord of the Rings, mixed with other sources, where you seem to be playing something that might be (again very loosely) seen as Sauron returning in an incredibly weakened human-like state. A decent and interesting promise, certainly something that's been explored before, but not in AVN context.
SIDE NOTE: btw, if you're into LotR setting [not sexual], I refer you to Nick Perumov's trilogy "The Ring of Darkness" (1993), which started out as fanfic set in Tolkien's M-E 300 years after War of the Ring, and later on got published (originally in Russian, not sure if there is English translation published, but there surely is some coop-translation available at least). These are some fully fledged thick novels that, beside the theme, are pretty decent literature dealing with the stuff Tolkien might find inconvenient, were he to live now -- the exploration of how people may later on view many of the things done by the "good guys" in LotR/previous M-E books; Perumov has since become a respected fantasy writer in his own right.
So, back to SoF.
[Ep1]
This part has sandbox elements, which are thankfully gone by Ep2. While the sandbox is not very burdensome, it feels contrived -- mostly because it remains for 80% emnpty, but you can inadvertedly skip minor elements of story, if you do not check every location every time.
There is a lot of content in Episede 1, yet 90% of it is babble. Not only loads of conversations, but also practically every dialogue line will have 2 or more lines of MC's thoughts, which doubles the reading amount.
Nevertheless, in his very circumlocutional way the dev is trying to build a grand story, and has done a lot of work.
MC is supposed to be revived/summoned back to his followers' controlled territory, but something goes amiss and he is recreated(?) at some small village on some remote island. His magical power battery almost at zero, so he is supposedly trying to refill his powers and get bearings.
The episode deals with him assembling some company and travelling across sea, and then to some old ruins where he has lots of memories, and starting to gain some power.
Unfortunately for those of us who expect an AVN on this site to have some sexual content, there is practically none; and where there is, it's all very basic little vanilla.
Reason: MC is not really interested in sex. He is above it, he apparently doesn't enjoy it very much even when it happens. How's that for a twist in a porn game site. So he waits until the girls offer themselves, and goes "well, ok, if you want it...", and then later on they are graetful for it and he is obsequiously nice about it. As in normal speech MC is quite dominant, here he becomes a wet blanket. Worst place where it could happen, if you tag your game mdom, actually, yeah? And you're DARK LORD for Pete's sake. Even if you don't yourself enjoy physically dominating others anymore, you might consider doing so to more fully corrupt the targets and advance your plans of world domination or whatever it is the MC seems to be aiming to do.
MC's recurring thought during Ep1 and 2, is that he is very weakened and is gaining magical power very very slowly.
I perked up first as I read this, as I thought he'd find out that sex does it for him (allow to gain power faster). Nope.
Thought maybe darker deeds do it for him, torture or whatever. Domination. He hasn't tried and probably won't. Also, no BDSM in tags.
Afraid it might turn out to be love, at which point the game is officially shitting unicorns and coloring itself pink.
I mean, a dark lord? Don't make me laugh.
The dev claims he dislikes mindless sex. Which is fine and dandy, but he abhors apparently also sex used as weapon, means of corruption, torture, or anything like that. Actually now I think about it, the sex scenes possibly are so bland because they might seem mindless to dev -- why would you link sex with violence or with domination. Ahm... okay... duhh.
[Ep2]
I think Ep1 gave impression of how the game looks, so this is just a brief overview of a couple points, the length of content is more and quite adequate.
UI looks very nice.
There's decent amount of content, 95% of which is not sexual, but more about building power/corruption. Sorta okayish.
Humanoid children of gods and of dragons appear.
MC is thinking all kinds of power fantasy thoughts, which are all very abstract level: when I become lord of everything, you will bend to my will etc.
Clearly, he has no human concepts of enjoying power over others physically. He does punch down a female barbarian clan leader, but... again, lacks any human-relatable concept of claiming his victory and cementing his hold. She has to ask him to do it herself. Which he proceeds to do in another vanilla scene.
And so on.
I will have a look at next update, when/if it happens, maybe things improve. That last episode with barbarian queen was sorta starting to turn out okay, if the dev builds from this we might actually get somewhere. As it is, as a reader I don't care about MCs grand plans unless they are matched by some action in flesh.