Idk about others, but my review said the game has been in development for 8 years, and now had barely any content, so I was recommending not to play it. Mod tanked it, without citing any rule I had broken.
I do think that talking about the dev's poor behavior should have it's place in a review tho, but that's just me.
The review rules are pretty strict. You can absolutely get away with whatever rating you want as long as your overwhelming focus is on the game itself. You can always mention the development in a sentence or two that fits in with your review. The best way to do it is to mention the version you’re reviewing and then take it from there.
The mods will remove anything they see as review bombing whenever a new update hits, especially a major game where defenders start reporting said reviews. I’ll give you two examples.
A: Dc removed most of the game and made almost nothing in two years of development. Fucking scam artist, has made an “update” that’s more like a dog shit down grade. - 1 star.
B: Current version. The recent partial update has left this game in a mess, unfinished new art, missing audio and ofc the majority of the old game missing makes for a pretty bad experience. Replaying old content over and ago isn’t exactly entertaining an I’m also not fond of the new pieces of writing. - In addition the development cycle seems to be in a quagmire which is imo evident in the downgrade of content and the extremely long periods of time in between updates. The current state of this game/ latest update plus the dev cycle context doesn’t inspire confidence, which means I can’t recommend the game in this state. I would hold off on giving this a go at a later state when the game is hopefully more complete. - 1 star.
Now you can write B with a lot less words than that, but the pedantic point is obvious. Keeping the focus on the actual latest version of the game makes it more likely to stay. Anyone can read plenty about the criticism of DC and the development in more details itt. After a few pages new players can see the discontent and draw their own conclusion.