So, lets begin with things I liked. I liked the girls, for the most part. They're nice looking, some are interesting, others kinda dull. And while slow, I did kinda like the beginning of the game. I like the idea of trying to figure out (as the MC) what you want while having a girl friend you loved. It was an interesting start to a game you don't see very often on here, that you're actually with someone at the start.
Now to stuff I didn't like. Sadly, they went absolutely nowhere with the beginning and that you were in a relationship. It just quickly gets shoved to the side and then ends. Doesn't really feel merited, for it to just end like it did. That said I didn't like the girlfriend very much (I can't remember her name). While I did like some of the characters, who had more interesting background, like you're sister, or Shortcake, some of the others were so one sided and flat they became boring so fast.
If that was all, this would be a 4 star game, but sadly, that is not all. The 2nd biggest problem I have with this game is the MC. You play as the MC in every game on this site, it's super important to like them. This MC just sucks so much. He's a pushover, seems dumb as a post sometimes, can't seem to catch even the most obvious things. He's just infuriating sometimes, a huge step back from the 1st person MC's of Mr. Dots first 2 games.
However, the worst part, by far, is the writing. The English is perfectly fine, good spelling and all, but it's like it's written for a 10 year old. There is no subtlety in anything. The MC and other characters have so many inner thoughts - its as if the dev thinks we, the player, can't understand anything that's going without telling us 5 times! It's so bad. A lot of the dialogue is also just very simple, and childish. I played through the whole first episode and when the 2nd one came out, just couldn't be bothered to play because of having to read it all.
I'm someone the enjoys a good story, I like the slow play, love great characters, this game is just lacking in so much of that. Mr. Dots is/was at their best when making personal 1 on 1 budding romance stories. The first chapter of DMD, and first part of the 2nd chapter, were very good as you build your relationship with Dee. Same with the first half of Melody. Sadly, the writing and storytelling start to drag those games down after that. The problem in SL is there is no personal 1 on 1 relationship to build. It could be your sister, but you spend much of the game hunting others. The time spent with your sister seems very shallow compared to other efforts of relationship building they've done.
In the end, it's a nice game to look at. If it was a movie, you could mute it and just watch, it would be fine. Sadly, that's not the case with this. Oh, and the music, it needs to be set to each scene, instead of just playing on a loop, it takes away from some scenes big time. Play this if you like to see pretty girls and nice renders, but don't expect much depth or storytelling.