Alright quit your big brain theories people, I just got to the end of the Deryl fight/Laurie death in my replay, my thoughts:
1. The Deryl Dilemma
I forgive Deryl a little more now as I think I have a better grasp on why the flying fuck he did what he did.
-Deryl was brainwashed by Jake to love Ella.
-He gains his powers and receives an order/condition or whatever from Charlie and Ella tells him to STAY PUT.
-He constructs PM Office Deryl, Alice Mansion Deryl, and works on Del.
-Deryl's stupid cocky nature gets the best of him WHILE STILL UNDER THE UNDYING LOVE INFLUENCE, he sends PM Office Deryl to attack the MC and Jake of his own volition to prove himself to Ella.
-After the MC finishes PM Office Deryl, the MC goes to fight ORIGINAL DERYL and during the fight, he breaks his brainwashing but still has Charlie's stigma.
-Deryl loses control of himself for whatever reason, and fails to evolve (this in part is probably done by Charlie's stigma; as mentioned with Shen getting to his 4th Evolve before Cole via a deal with said stigma).
-By Charlie's order he goes back to Ella's base to finish the hearts, but before Original Deryl loses complete control to his nature, he floods Alice Basement Deryl with his humanity and what not through pure instinct to preserve what little of himself before monsterfication fully took over.
-Del is also finished before hand, and joins H.E.R.O leaking the MC's documents in order to force Alice Basement Deryl to get closer back to the original via plot, of Del's own free will mind you.
-The Diamond War commences and the Deryl Chimera's are monsters so of course they act as bodyguards so that cocky Original now Monster Deryl can fight the MC one on one for literally no reason other than to be a prick.
-After all the Deryls minus Alice Basement join up with the Original, he becomes remade and Evolved, as he wanted for himself from the get go, but he is incomplete, allowing the Monsterifed state to still take hold, even if the Alice Basement Deryl joined up, he would still love swallowed up by the Original's monster nature.
-The MC beats this Deryl, weakening it, so that when the last Deryl joins up it's a more complete Evolution, thus restoring Original Deryl, and all the Deryls after.
He's still a massive cunt for it, but if it was me (save for fighting my friends for no reason) I probably would've done the same with luring Basement me back to my original self.
2. The Laurie Saving Conditions
So this part is fucking RIDICULOUS to me. At first I thought the ONLY way to save Laurie was because Deryl got a special healing serum from Aglaecwif (he even mentions trading a few things), and that's why we could only save her going Right. But upon reading the dialogue; Deryl uses his evolution blood, and of course our skill check and Deryl win.
There is virtually NO GOD DAMN REASON why we can't just go Left, meet Aglaecwif, request Skill as a prize, and STILL save Laurie...shit even all of the Deryl fights checks remain the same save for the Hesitate/Do Not Hesitate.
I really wish you could do both, as there is no reason for you not to if Deryl isn't even using anything he doesn't have in his possession already...it sucks and will probably be the one thing I'll always hold against W.W; still love them tho.
Anywho that's my summary of everything up to that point via going Right. I still need to go Left again and read everything with Valravn, and then go play through the rest of the after War content once more. But overall, it was fun going back ALLL the way through and being better well informed and catching stuff I missed previously. Hopefully my terrible memory will cease from a 5th god damn replay.