It leads into the question of "Did Weird World rush too early into the HERO stuff?"
Alice is most definitely the most well written romance option in the game currently especially since she is a very central figure in the arc involving Klaus which allowed us to build up a good idea of who she is and if we wanted her.
My primary issue is I believe Weird rushed too quickly into the HERO stuff since whatever we are doing involving the girls will ALWAYS be overshadowed by the much larger events going on with HERO and SIN as well.
Although in fairness Emily and the other girls are also overshadowed by Alice and Klaus stuff as well since that arc was major enough that we kinda forget about the other girls while we focus on Klaus and Alice.
I feel like if we had a series of other arcs for the other girls early on that would of perhaps improved things for those girls. I mean Liz has her whole NTR thing (although we can save her) it didn't really hit with me.
I liked the whole thing of helping Emily build up confidence but it fell into the background in comparison to the events ongoing (was very mundane for a super fella honestly).
Amber...well the whole cam girl thing (it not being her) and supporting her while pretending to be Liz was uh meh...I guess Weird is going to do something major with them in the next update but I feel like its too little too late (since its very far into the game already most people already have a set I do like or don't like of them).
We do have 2 potential other main girls that Weird has eluded to them having a greater presence.
Mia and Claudia.
Mia was our magical mcguffin that we just had to save despite not knowing her long at all (I mean she is a cute flat chest girl so I dig her).
Claudia is fucking main girl material and so damn wholesome...if Weird does her right she'll overshadow Alice easily.
Edit: Oh yeah Tiffany...forgot she existed again. I feel like again, if we waited a bit longer for the HERO stuff Tiffany's whole romance could of been tied in fucking amazingly with the HERO stuff but we haven't seen her much.
TLDR: I feel like W.W rushed too fast into HERO stuff which led to the other girls being overshadowed although they were still overshadowed by Alice's arc with Klaus.
Yep. Alice is basically apart of every major arc. From the frat party, to the Klaus Arc, Jake fight, joining HERO and then the Battle of Diamonds. She's ever presence which means she can exert her dominance and stake her claims on the MC.
I slightly disagree on the Tiffany bit though. She's actually established enough that she's basically our Ice Queen. We plotted with her, worked together to fight the Minyaks, infiltrated HERO, took her virginity while she gave us a heads up about HERO and then there's her wedding where we cucked her husband. She's also up to no good again, which will likely include us. So I would say Tiffany is pretty present, at least compared to the rest of our women.
After Alice and Tiffany, it's basically Emily, Liz, and Amber in 3rd place, in terms of screen time. Maybe add Brianna to it as well. After them though, this is where the fling comment comes into play and some might disagree but Ella is head fling. She's barely around, she's hardly committed to being together while preferring to be our stalker. Then there's the constant plotting behind the scenes from her. She might as well not be a love interest with how absent she has been. Though, I'm sure that'll change.
I agree with what you said about joining HERO too early though. It's what disrupted most of our women's scenes the most. Especially since some are human or too weak to be involved. That said, we do get more time to develop the ones that were in game for a very long time like Alexis. She predates Demi, Angelina and technically even Tiffany and Brianna, if you count the Dead End. So it's not all bad because I'm finally getting my superhuman waifu.
All that said, no one beats Mommy 4th. She's literally linked to our soul and is always with us. That's why she's the best!