Version: 0.5.21
I'll give it a 2.49/5 because I'm not rounding up.
I enjoyed it at the beginning, but find myself losing interest as the story goes on.
First of all, the branches. I played using the mod, otherwise the game makes you pick just 2 of the 3 groups to investigate. This time constraint feels artificial as the case was cold at the start of the game, and was only reopened because of a pushy teacher. Why do we not have enough time to investigate all 3? And within each branch is a sub-branch between two specific people to investigate. Again - why would we only investigate one of these people?
The choices don't really matter. It's either; Do you want to sleep with this person? or, How would you like the next lines of dialogue to go? Before it continues on with no lasting changes in the MC or others' personalities. Not only that, the MC just makes dumb decisions in general. Everything is moved forward 'for the case' which takes the human element completely out of it. Even if you decide the MC is mad about a situation, he's over it after a couple lines of dialogue.
Also, the choices don't seem to track. Characters often make vague comments about a scene that never happened because I rejected them. The script just assumes you're fucking everyone all the time.
Each of the three branches comes with one forced LI, and various other characters. Some avoidable, some not (talking about lewd scenes). Also, in each of these groups, there is 1 antagonist that doesn't like/trust the MC, but everyone else either instantly or quickly grows to love the MC. I've grown to dislike most of the LI's at this point for one reason or another, including all of the mandatory ones. But in defense of some of them, it's often because of how they reacted to some dumb shit the MC does. The only characters I even care about at this point are Josie, Iona, and Oleysa.
Quality-wise, the renders are good. The animations are robotic, though. There are also a lot of continuity errors between renders due to reusing previous renders from the scene (characters go from standing, to kneeling, back to standing, just based on which character is in focus while talking).
Honestly, the best way to describe it is... the writers came up with a scene, and described what was happening in the scene. They then played a couple rounds of 'telephone' before it got to the artists and we're left with narration of actions that just don't happen. In the lewd scene with Monika, they go from cowgirl to missionary ONLY for the moneyshot render, but the narration is still as if she's in cowgirl.
The Asami lewd scene was just very poorly done. Pretty sure the MC's dick is missing texture in one render, and its such a big difference between narration and what is shown on the renders at the end.
Now, the detective mechanics are pretty cool. There is a conspiracy board to keep track of all characters and their connections to the victims and groups that updates whenever the MC learns something interesting. There are clues you can click on during the game, and "flashbacks" to bring up, but these are mostly in the beginning of the game. Would be cool if this was more involved with more hidden clues to find.
I expected more, and the game started off a lot better than the last couple of updates have delivered. We've gone through 3 'parts' of investigation which each group, and now they're marked finished. Don't know if it means finished for the update, or if we're moving onto another step. I hope it turns around - I really do - but I also hope that at the end of the story we can throw most of the people in jail or get them expelled or something.
I'll give it a 2.49/5 because I'm not rounding up.
I enjoyed it at the beginning, but find myself losing interest as the story goes on.
First of all, the branches. I played using the mod, otherwise the game makes you pick just 2 of the 3 groups to investigate. This time constraint feels artificial as the case was cold at the start of the game, and was only reopened because of a pushy teacher. Why do we not have enough time to investigate all 3? And within each branch is a sub-branch between two specific people to investigate. Again - why would we only investigate one of these people?
The choices don't really matter. It's either; Do you want to sleep with this person? or, How would you like the next lines of dialogue to go? Before it continues on with no lasting changes in the MC or others' personalities. Not only that, the MC just makes dumb decisions in general. Everything is moved forward 'for the case' which takes the human element completely out of it. Even if you decide the MC is mad about a situation, he's over it after a couple lines of dialogue.
Also, the choices don't seem to track. Characters often make vague comments about a scene that never happened because I rejected them. The script just assumes you're fucking everyone all the time.
Each of the three branches comes with one forced LI, and various other characters. Some avoidable, some not (talking about lewd scenes). Also, in each of these groups, there is 1 antagonist that doesn't like/trust the MC, but everyone else either instantly or quickly grows to love the MC. I've grown to dislike most of the LI's at this point for one reason or another, including all of the mandatory ones. But in defense of some of them, it's often because of how they reacted to some dumb shit the MC does. The only characters I even care about at this point are Josie, Iona, and Oleysa.
Quality-wise, the renders are good. The animations are robotic, though. There are also a lot of continuity errors between renders due to reusing previous renders from the scene (characters go from standing, to kneeling, back to standing, just based on which character is in focus while talking).
Honestly, the best way to describe it is... the writers came up with a scene, and described what was happening in the scene. They then played a couple rounds of 'telephone' before it got to the artists and we're left with narration of actions that just don't happen. In the lewd scene with Monika, they go from cowgirl to missionary ONLY for the moneyshot render, but the narration is still as if she's in cowgirl.
The Asami lewd scene was just very poorly done. Pretty sure the MC's dick is missing texture in one render, and its such a big difference between narration and what is shown on the renders at the end.
Now, the detective mechanics are pretty cool. There is a conspiracy board to keep track of all characters and their connections to the victims and groups that updates whenever the MC learns something interesting. There are clues you can click on during the game, and "flashbacks" to bring up, but these are mostly in the beginning of the game. Would be cool if this was more involved with more hidden clues to find.
I expected more, and the game started off a lot better than the last couple of updates have delivered. We've gone through 3 'parts' of investigation which each group, and now they're marked finished. Don't know if it means finished for the update, or if we're moving onto another step. I hope it turns around - I really do - but I also hope that at the end of the story we can throw most of the people in jail or get them expelled or something.