The argument "beware what you wish for" Is out of reality because even if you make all the negative decisions for both you and anne he ends up getting Fucked in vacation in both original and revamped edition.
That's not what I mean. The MC initiates their games because he thinks it'll spice up their sex life, because he gets off on it, and because it's what
he wants. Anne goes along and enjoys it, and at first it does seem to energize their own sex life. But as the story progresses, the MC keeps pushing Anne into sexual encounters without any indication that it's still a couple-based activity. She recognizes that this is no longer about them, it's about
him. Meanwhile, she's getting a ton of really enjoyable sex with whoever she wants (which, the narrative eventually hints, is what she was like before she settled down with the MC). The two conditions combine to make her seek out her own sexual enjoyment without worrying about what the MC wants, and eventually to cheat on him and lie about it. This is a state of affairs (wordplay intended) that the husband caused, and over which he no longer has any control. The genie's out of the bottle and the husband no longer knows where he tossed the cork. Meanwhile, Anne's being sodomized by the genie and loving it.
Now, in a properly written and properly coded game, one of two things would be true. The first is that this is where the game was always headed, no matter what, and from the moment they started playing their sexual games the relationship was either doomed or fated to settle into a constant stream of both open and adulterous affairs. The second is that there's a way to maintain boundaries, love, and trust while still having sex with others, and that while a "doomed" or "fated" relationship is still quite probable, it's not the only possible outcome. That's what the previous version attempted but failed to accomplish.
Whether or not the MC has sex with others in the original is utterly irrelevant. It's there for the player's optional enjoyment. (I suspect that, eventually, the pregnancy storyline would've affected their relationship, but we never got there. Probably Ellen, too.) Only the player's choices regarding Anne actually matter. In the revamp, though — at least so far — the MC having sex with others
still doesn't matter. All that matters is whether or not he's honest about it.
The be "honest to your wife" argument Is also a false argument. You dont get the chance to disquss different terms in your sexual relationship in both editions.
In the case of the revamp, this is wrong. The MC's honesty (or lack thereof) specifically trips a variable that leads to acceptance, a kinda-bad outcome, or a game over.
Only way to stay faithfull and keep her happy Is to stay sexually inactive with strangers. And do that while anne Fucks everyone and everything that walks around, and As your sexual life with her declines to zero at Last 3-4 chapters. Transformed Into a total cuckold Is the forced option to be faithfull to her
Again, not true. In the original, the husband can sit around at home, work, watch movies, nap, go to the gym, or screw/impregnate anyone with a vagina, and the only effect is Anne complaining about it. It's the choices regarding Anne that determine whether or not she's going to cheat and what sort of relationship they're going to have. It's just not written/coded coherently. Now, in the revamp, the husband's non-Anne choices
do matter. At least so far.
It's not perfect — the MC still doesn't tell her absolutely everything — but it's much better than the original. And if they have a relationship in which they trust each other to not break the rules whether or not they've discussed it beforehand, which the positive version of Anne's three reactions to
Elena suggests they do, that's fine.
Mentioning Nicole i dont think you get to fuck her at all at the 4 revamped chapters.
Yes you do.
In the revamp, Anne can have actual sex (not just fondling or teasing) with
up to three men in Punta Cana, plus a path-exclusive encounter with either another man, a woman, or a pair of men. Then another path-exclusive encounter with
one of two men (one of them hasn't progressed to penetrative sex yet, but based on the original we know it's going to). Whereas the MC can have actual sex (not just fondling or teasing) with
two masseuses, between one and three (some path-exclusive) women in Punta Cana, and two or three path-exclusive women once they're back home (I don't remember if
Naomi is path-exclusive vs. Nicole/January or not). That's pretty even. Did some of those scenes come at the cost of husband/wife scenes? Maybe; I'm not going to go back to the original and check. But then again there was a whole bunch of new (and frankly more storyline-appropriate) sexual content added to replace it, so I think it's a wash.