As usual with my reviews, renders do not really affect my scoring, for the most part.
I do however have a slight change to that in this case based on the animations. Ive done some daz animations, so I know they are hard, and a lot of the reasons why. So first, I will say most of the animation in this game are bad. But that is not why I am deducting. It is because they chose to put animation in a lot of bad places, and that they tried too hard with the animations without the skill to back it up.
To clarify, very basic animations can be.... "good enough". Its when you try getting into more advanced animations where things start to go bad without lots of skill. Example, guy boning girl. If its just his hips moving, its a "good enough" basic animation, but its lacking extra movement to be advanced (head/arm/tits/etc moving). Those things can make it look more realistic but ONLY if done correctly which is VERY hard to do without lots of skill (way more than I have). This dev tried... but failed to get those more advanced ones and instead of just going back to simple ones until they leveled up, they used them anyways. That was a bad decision in my opinion. They were very frequent and constantly just hard to watch. To the point where about 30% through I stopped looking at the renders anytime I thought I noticed animation happening.
The girls in general were actually pretty good looking. Without that bad choice with animations I would have given it an extra star.
Now... the first star was lost from this icky feeling I got so many times in this game. This feeling that something is or is going to happen to one of your LIs. That shit that only the cucks like. I almost didnt play this game, because for some reason I thought it was an NTR game. But someone told me it wasnt and I double checked the tags. So I tried it. But nonstop feeling like shit is about to happen to the girls made me re-check the tags like 5 times. Maybe some people like that feeling that some major drama is about to happen to take your LIs in their porn game, but I don't.
So at least twice I actually asked again "You sure X is not going to happen?" and was told "no, just keep playing". I was actually sure at one point they were purposely trying to lead me into a NTR scene because they thought it would be funny since they know I hate that shit.
- First, the shit with Sophia and the rapist? That is borderline NTR to me. First of all, she was knocked out COLD for 3 full nights with him. The chances that he didnt do anything to her until the 4th night? ZIP. So the player is left basically assuming that she is being raped by him for a VERY LONG portion of the game. The dev then uses dialog to say that no, she wasnt, but he STARTED to try to touch her on the 4th night and she woke up and stopped it so nothing happened? My brain wont buy that. So that was basically a full star there for either misleading, or very badly thought out story.
- Second, The shit with the daughter joining THS. I had an idea early on that I should have said no, because it felt like a trap. You saw what happened to Jenny. Both in her induction (parading her nude in front of everyone, then her being spanked). And then you obviously saw all the shit you did to her as her master. So I just had a bad feeling that submitting you daughter to them was asking for trouble. But again... I was advised not to worry about it and to just try it. And... having made it to the end of content so far (day 35) I am now more confident shit will be fine... but the dev led me through some not fun shit before I got there. A very LONG period of game time where they tell you that before she will be approved, you have to let ANOTHER master have her for TWO DAYS. After you were promised you would be her ONLY MASTER EVER. So you get there and suddenly feel like you made a bad decision (unless you are a cuck and like that shit). It is not until later when you find out the secret that helps ease your mind (a little.. still not totally 100% sure).
Overall, those 2 things each cost a star (the choice to use bad-advanced animations instead of good-basic animations) and the constant need by the dev to make you feel like your girls are in danger. Both of those detracted a LOT from this game for me.
Oh, and the AAAOOOOOOUUUHHH!!!! used for every sex moan started to get really annoying. You dont want to hear the sound my brain came up with for that... and it has no place in sex scenes. But that is minor enough to not count for my review.
Some other minor nitpicking that maybe constructive criticism for the dev:
- Lots of awkward transitions from scene to scene. Having sex, then sitting at dinner table with family. From one image to the next. Very jarring.
- Lots of scenes that needed a new image. Fucking her throat, but now it says you put her on her back. Still shows throatfuck. Then you fuck her, still shows same image. Then you move again. Too many VERY different things have happened to still be showing the throatfuck image.
- Vague choice descriptions. Some of them are VERY hard to tell what they mean. I had to click through some, then go back and change my choice once I saw what it was. Make them more clear. Although.... after digging through the code, 90% of them make no difference except for small dialog. But most users will NOT know that.
- Big gaps with daughter. I know some users (like me) are 90% in this for the daughter content. Incest is best. Dont argue with me. But after doing shit with the daughter, there is a HUUUUUUUGE gap where there is NOTHING with her. It also felt very.. unrealistic. She was begging for his cock one day, and then 2 weeks later hasnt even mentioned it, given him looks, tried anything, etc? Honestly felt like I had broken the game with a bad choice for a while.
- re-use of some dialog. There were at least a couple of scenes where the wording were 100% copy pasted. The one where duaghter describes her first girl/girl experience to the friend, then later to father? I am confident that was a literal copy/paste with just the name changed from friend to father.
- Image re-use of sex scenes. To many of the sex scenes looked exactly the same but with just slightly diff text. Not a huge issue as most sandbox type games do that a lot, but still annoying.
- floating girls. MANY sex scenes had girls hovering. Especially during animations. I feel like the artist was too busy trying to get poses and shit done that they forgot to look and say "Hrmmmm, is she even touching the bed?"
But the overall theme of the game was not horrible. With some fixes it could be much better.
My issue is that I feel the game gets too close to some NTR-like shit. Its like it is getting right up to the line without going over. This makes me scared that the dev might suddenly toss in actual NTR shit near the end of the game, so I likely will not play it again until it is completed so I can read comment and verify that did not happen. Which sucks, because I kinda want to like it.