Review Version: Ch. 2
Review Score: 4.4/5
Story
“The Missing Part” is a heavily cinematic story with a specific theme in mind: dealing with loss. The plot - following the “Tragedy” style of storytelling - immediately sets the tone by exposing the audience to not just one, but two instances within the prologue of an inflection point. A key issue slowly arises though as the inflection points also fill the role of an inciting incident, which puts the author in the uncomfortable position of further creating tragedy to justify the following three acts in order to maintain an interesting story.
With the project still being early in development it’s difficult to provide further analysis of the story. So far the audience is exposed to three separate subplots to follow - each of which can be avoided if the audience doesn’t enjoy a particular character - alongside the primary plot tying it all together. It’s unclear how much influence each subplot will have in driving the story forward, but each one appears to bring unique revelations to the table that beautifully add depth to the world.
Characters
Within the prologue we’re introduced to several characters that play a prominent role in the story, three of which are the focus of the subplots mentioned above. While the protagonist’s best friend and his wife are interesting in their own regard, it’s obvious the author has invested considerable time and resources fleshing out the love interests as each one is foreshadowed cleverly within the prologue.
Lisa is the most interesting of the three love interests as she appears to come from a sheltered background. The juxtaposition of her empathetic nature contrasted with her mother’s blunt behavior incorporates a wide range of personalities she can fit into at any given time. She’s perhaps the best match for the protagonist in terms of long term love as she compliments his reserved nature (triggered by the grief from the prologue). It’s easy to feel her warmth every time she speaks, or to hear her excitement when discussing her passion. Lisa is the logical choice in partner if the audience was unable to exert control over the protagonist’s decision.
Complimenting Lisa is Hailey: a motivated young woman with a streak of immaturity at times. Her potential relationship with the protagonist faces some difficult hurdles though due to the age difference of two decades, the power dynamic between her and the protagonist, and her history of issues with her parents. Any relationship that forms will always be plagued by the questions of: “does she really love the protagonist?”, or “does she feel indebted to him?”. It’s a tough romance plot to navigate as an author as few avenues lead to a satisfying outcome. However, Hailey’s youth may become irrelevant if her story arc can sell her maturity through her history growing up.
Sarah is perhaps the odd one out as she fills the gap between Lisa and Hailey. Her bold personality also compliments the other two love interests by filling out the trio of desirable traits. Her status as a bachelorette is supported by her sharing traits with Madelyn (the protagonist’s daughter), which alleviates the issues with her feeling the most incompatible with the protagonist. Ironically, her personality partially mimicking Maddy’s also contradicts the protagonist moving on from his past. Sarah could potentially serve as a constant reminder of what the protagonist lost.
Conclusion
Why the 4 stars? Despite glowing praise in most of the project it’s difficult to overlook the issues surrounding the oppressiveness of the tragedy element driving the story. Sarah and Lisa are examples due to them serving as reflections of Maddy and Ella respectively, which positions half of the love interests as more grief prone than Hailey.
Additionally, the protagonist abruptly shifts personality in each of the subplots. In one scene he’s hesitant to take action due to his crippling grief, only for the next scene to show him suddenly acting confident. His character growth is hindered as the audience doesn’t experience the methodical transition from a broken, empty husk into someone full of warmth and life. It’s a shame too as all of the characters were elegantly positioned to grow synchronously with intricate paths for them to impact the other.
Overall I still highly recommend this project. The care and passion is on full display by the author, and that ultimately prevents the above mentioned shortcomings from detracting from the experience.