Also, Innocent Witches has come a long way since it was released and is very different from what it was like in the past. If you played or hated it before I suggest giving it another go. (Check out the thumbnail preview images of how it has changed since). https://f95zone.to/threads/innocent-witches-v0-5a-sad-crab.330/
Interesting plot, some decision making so far, all in all quite enjoyable.
As a side note, "Ataegina" and "Reluctant archon" alongside "WVM" (left it out because it is doing REALLY well, definitely not underrated) are the only 3 games that make me feel like: "I can't wait for the next update".
The game has some of the best characters that I've seen in a game, in terms of writing and design; with a game mechanic (diaries) that let you know about the character's currents thoughts/feelings towards MC and the events that hey both share.
The game isn't that popular, I don't know why, even tho everyone that I recommend it to loves it.