I've check all subforums and this looks like the most appropriate to me, because it's a game recommendation to NOT play one, which many times is an even better recommendation because it could save your time/effort/money/the like.
Again, your thread is NOT about not recommending games but a place to rant. If you truly wanted to let people know if a specific game should or should not be played you would use the review system.
For this thread I'm absolutely not focusing in either only one aspect, or only in the story. The only remotely closer reason I could think why you thought that, is that the idea for a thread about unrecommending games came from another thread which is dedicated to game stories.
Or it could be from the fact that your first post about a game focuses solely on writing and story. You mention nothing about
game mechanics
sound
graphic
gameplay
difficulty
bugs
Of course it could help change something, the fact that people would be able to read critical opinions about games which usually don't get them, because they are either buried by fanbois or shielded by a faux prestige which was created in echo chambers, is reason enough for this thread to be constructive and helpful.
You mean OTHER than the review section, the CORRECT place to recommend or not recommend playing that specific game?
could it be that you made this thread because you know the review section doesn't allow your style of game bashing?
Also it could help people to play games which are better suited for them,
which would require recommendations which this thread is the opposite of....
Only positive vibes here.
" written by a 12 years old boy with 0 experience about real, actual 18 to 50 women. "
" The other women are taken out of a 12 years old boy fantasy, very shocking for a man which had sons, you can presume he had to deal with at least a woman. "
You and I clearly have VERY different ideas of what "positive vibes" means
That's only your opinion, not actual reality.
No it's an observation, with you mixing up "serious story" and "realistic story", with you complaining about no harems in a game that never hinted, tagged or promised one etc. etc. etc.
Playing 75% of a game is enough to have an opinion, specially if it's 75% of such a terrible game.
75% is made up, without having finished the game you have no actual way of calculating how much was left and so no way to calculate how much you played.
I'm sure you wouldn't need to eat 100% of something disgusting to know it's disgusting and that you don't want or need to eat 100% of it in order to get a more complete opinion on the fact.
This is a flawed point, unless the meal is brought out piece by piece over months and the chef slowly tries to improve the next portion coming out.... trying to compare a complete meal served all at once with a incomplete game that releases updates months apart and the dev has time to get feed back, add things, fix bugs etc. makes no sense.
That is right, you assumed, that is on you.
It's the more precise analogy I can think of when reading those unreal situations and dialogues, it's not meant to be an insult but the most accurate depiction of the showcased lack of actual knowledge of the real adult world.
So you have read many stories written by 12 year olds? clearly you would have to in order to compare and then make the analogy.
Also you clearly made another mistake here, what makes you think a adult porn game HAS to take knowledge from "the real adult world" even if a porn game or story takes inspiration from the real world it's also meant to make fantasies come true.
Lastly, where in the tags, the overview or in the game itself does the game say, offer or imply it is meant to be a realistic, true to the real world representation?
Again, flawed expectations and false assumptions on your part, NONE of which the game encourages....
F95zone is, quoting from "About us":
F95zone is an adult community where you can find tons of great adult games and comics [...]
So adult is the key word here, and definitely writting like a 12 years old boy isn't adult.
As you keep bringing it up, again I ask:
So you have read many stories written by 12 year olds? clearly you would have to in order to compare and then make the analogy.
I don't, that's why I said this:
"This is the point I might be more biased to think this isn't any kind of groundbreaking element in the history of storytelling [...]"
It's as clear as anyone can be, I clearly acknowledge my opinion about that part might be biased because of my personal experience.
Except you CLAIM you are writing this for the benefit of others by pointing out the flaws and this is a flaw specific to you. So it would have no influence on anyone but you.
Also personal experiences of these types of cases differ, you ignore that and the fact that the dev might be using writing techniques to illicit responses from the player. By calling it a flaw you are saying only your experience is right and what the dev tried to do is wrong.
I couldn't care less if that piece of work of a game had a full harem or not,
You couldn't care less? well your point 4 seems to contradict that statement....
" 4º I couldn't put up with the game for long, but from what I know from my gameplay experience and what I read from others, you get a hentai harem in place just to be required to end up with only one. And the story is presented, as hard as it could, for you to end up with the BPD. Really? The game sets up a hentai harem for you just to be REQUIRED to choose only one? I get it had to be the BPD because it's the author own daughter, but then why setting up the harem story. "
That is one long winded "I couldn't care less", also if you couldn't care less then why list it as a flaw?
EVERYTHING else displayed about either monogamous relationships, or casual sex, or promiscuous sex is wrong.
except in porn games.... because it's... you know... a GAME
Not by the dozen but I've known enough, male and female. Also an ex-girlfriend of mine was approached to become one.
This might be strange for most but it isn't uncommon in main cities, cities with big universities and areas with big military bases, it's where most of them are and are inducted.
Ok let's for argument sake say that is even remotely true, YOU who is soooo fixated on realism and the real world, YOU are saying that because you know "Not by the dozen" but "enough" that you know what ALL of them are like, what ALL of them think, what ALL of them feel, how ALL of them act, ALL the time.....
Just re-read what YOU wrote in YOUR reply, then I would advice a trip to the hardware shop because at this rate you are going to run out of shovels very quickly....
So it's not like I want real life spies in my porn games, but I don't like the 12 years old boy version of a female spy passing as if it was somehow based on reality or even realistic.
You know you are just making stuff up now right? If you are going to make outrageous claims you should at least back it up with some sort of proof?
So where is your proof that the dev was basing the spy in reality or realistic spies.
Where is your proof that the dev was not maybe just inspired in part or whole by them?
and can you even tell the difference between based on and inspired by? and can you show us were the dev states what he was doing / thinking when he made the spy?
It's more probable for you to find a real life elf, dwarf or orc than a female spy like that.
Strange? because here I thought we were talking about a porn game in a fantasy world and NOT real life.
Seems like you are mixing up fantasy and reality again...
I'm being helpful already by warning about that shitty game, with a detailed explanation about how and why it's bad and wrong.
You mean, what you think is shitty about the
part of the game you played and gave a detailed explanation based on criteria, assumptions and expectations few if any others would have AND because YOU thought that part was useful, you could just add stuff to bash the game more?
I already addresed why eating the remaining 25% manure isn't going to change the fact that it's manure and that sadly I already ate 75% of it because I was misleaded by its prestige as a reference AVN.
and I have addressed that the 75% is made up and that your example makes no sense....
It's like living in a world where movies like The Room are considered among the best but others like L.A. Confidential are unknown indie projects, it should be the other way around because Leap of Faith is the The Room of AVNs.
Using your example, it doesn't mean the room was a bad movie, the camera doesn't shake all the time, the sound doesn't drop in and out, you don't see the boom drop into shot from time to time, the background music isn't so loud you can't hear the dialog but sure you ignore ALL that because it doesn't fit your taste and call it bad.... at least you didn't make up stuff to bash it.
If I wanted a thread to just spill hate on games, without any intention of it being helpful for someone, then I would have started it at off-topic because it looks like the most appropriate place for it.
Well your thread has been up for little over 2 days, had 549 views as of me writing this, you've managed to spill hate on one game and it doesn't seem like anyone is finding that one "unrecommended game post" helpful....
I don't know, the fact that the game was allegedly a tribute to the author's SUICIDED DAUGHTER might have created the ludicrous impression to me that it could be related to real events, or at the very least that the fiction parts were light. I know it's a silly assumption, but forgive me.
"the game was
allegedly a
tribute to the author's
SUICIDED DAUGHTER" Was it advertised as such? or did you read that somewhere and start making assumptions?
"it could be
related to real events" again, was it advertised as such, also "related to" in NO WAY says or implies it is based on, recreated as or directly portrayed. So basically you thought / assumed it
COULD be related and then bashed it for not being / doing something you weren't sure of in the first place.....
or to put it in a way you might understand
story : The sea our friend
you : what a shit story, there were no submarines even though the title said sea
you : seas have submarines so it's not a realistic way to show the sea
you: it was just a stupid story about 2 people living by the sea
you : see i'm being helpful
She is hot (and not the typical USA beauty they always put in movies and tv shows) and could seduce a dead man, but also emotionally as cold as they come and it took the nerd protagonist the whole fucking 4 or 5 seasons to make her fall for him (and it only happened because it's both a tv show and a comedy)
and yet.... in season 1 she was already disobeying orders based on her feelings....
He is an ice cold-blooded killer and ruthless manipulator, it took him the whole fucking 4 or 5 seasons to become somewhat human (and again, it only happened because it's both a tv show and a comedy)
and yet... he wasn't even a spy or a woman...
Did you see? They ARE based on real life spies.
The female spy does exactly what you say they can't / won't /don't
The male agent isn't a spy, is not a woman and does things you say spies don't / won't / can't
nope don't see at all...
Jack Reacher 1 is also the same, he plays a very well written spy-like character
This is one more reason to call your interpretation of things into question, while reacher (movie) does use spy-like acquaintances to surveille, collect information etc. He is nothing like a spy or spy-like and most of his actions or the actions he takes are no where near being considered spy-like or even covert.
I already explained this, but talking about fictional spy stories, there are TONS of books about real life spies and based on reality, written by authors which were either spies themselves, or do know the profession very well, like Frederick Forsyth or John le Carré.
BUT did the game ever claim to be trying to portray anyone realistically? or was that something you assumed from reading other members posts?
You keep bring up real world / realistic but have yet to provide anything to show that it is what the game promised and then didn't deliver.
Maybe you could explain why do you think that fame is warranted...
Simple, enough players found they were entertained, found a good fap scene or two or ten, enjoyed their time in the GAME.
Now you keep posting about YOUR personal opinions, assumptions and expectations, how about you post images, screen shots, quotes, anything, where the game advertises, implies or promises you all those things you have a problem with.
Because so far, you read some stuff from other people, came up with some ideas, played the game and it "surprise surprise" didn't have what you made up or read from others and now you want to bash it....