If we had been given the option, I would have dumped Audrey anyway once she started drastically changing her appearance about a day after you commit to a relationship. That's some bait and switch nonsense. The worst part of all, imo, was making a very permanent change (an ugly tattoo on her tit) "for you" without bothering to ask if you like that kind of thing, which I don't.
It would be kinda like surprising her with the news that you just got a dick reduction surgery, as a gift to her, without asking her opinion first.