Where to go with this one. It feels like somewhere between a 3 and a 4, which is also why I feel that the 5 star system should be 4 or 10 stars. Girls are ok if a little too slim for my liking and not a lot of variation when it comes to body. It’s clearly going for Harem but doesn’t commit to it. The femdom scene is supposedly optional, except it’s not if you like Carol. Which is sort of like giving you an option between no health insurance and health insurance ie not really optional. The MC looks too generic and like a twig could break him. The story kind of saves the VN since it hasn’t devolved to repetitive “I love you” and actually moves forward, which we see too often on this site.