Oh, thanks I guess I can at least go for the true Chaos ending then. I thought I could get all of the choices in one Chaos playthrough somehow. Thanks for the help, I might go for a third playtrhough then if there will still be enough new scenes to unlock to be worth it.Did you pick the option "I'll give her my strength" (paraphrased) at the end of the Alioth scenario? This option sets you up for the True Chaos route and disables the first choice. Now you can only choose to sacrifice the Dark Lords to stay on Chaos or the citizens of each nation to fully qualify for True Chaos.
If you wanted to pick the first option for the CG you need to either avoid the Alioth scenario or pick the "I want to make Anora happy" option.