Victoria in Big City [v0.25] - April 22, 2021
Story - 3/5
Not bad for the "moving to the big city" & "good girl gone bad" tropes but not great either. When it comes to the latter, I'm not sure if the developer purposely made it 'neutral girl gone bad' as Victoria doesn't exactly follow the good girl trope that well. What it lacks is a slow burn approach when it comes to relationships & sex especially since she's currently in a relationship & she's getting corrupted far too easily far too soon. If Victoria is going to be corrupted so much so soon, Katy needs to be a far worse influence than she currently is.
Writing - 1/5
In desperate need of an English proofreader as the writing is painful to read & is nothing short of horrid. The VN is over a year old (first post in the thread is March 15, 2020) & has had an update so there's no excuse for it to still be in this state. Literally everything is wrong from sentences not making sense, spelling errors, not understanding human speech in English to the point it sounds robotic/wrong, unnecessary conversation & I could go on. I think adding even some feminization to the dialog could go a long way & create more realism to the speech. In a game that is based around the 'good girl gone bad' cliche, I think some calmer language for Victoria is necessary until she gets worse or eventually becomes bad. Another issue is the font as it's hard to tell if the character is having a thought as it's hard to tell if it's in italics or not.
Art - 5/5
Everyone is stunning! Victoria & Katy are simply gorgeous. Backgrounds are great. Perfect.
Final Thoughts
Besides the writing being completely horrible & the lack of pacing that is necessary for a story of the "good girl gone bad" trope. It's still early enough in development to still have a lot of potential to be something good if not excellent with proper direction. The story does need some tweaking. What I would do is go back & make Katy an even worse influence as the reason why Victoria cheated so soon which can be done by rewriting & changing the dress Katy bought Victoria to something more skimpy.
Pros:
- Good concept
- Everyone is beautiful
- Follows the "moving to the city" trope well
- Has a lot of potential
Cons:
- Writing is horrible, even the title
- Story is lacking & needs pacing but it's fixable
- Bad font
- MC is more neutral than good for the "good girl gone bad" trope
Overall Rating - 3/5
Story - 3/5
Not bad for the "moving to the big city" & "good girl gone bad" tropes but not great either. When it comes to the latter, I'm not sure if the developer purposely made it 'neutral girl gone bad' as Victoria doesn't exactly follow the good girl trope that well. What it lacks is a slow burn approach when it comes to relationships & sex especially since she's currently in a relationship & she's getting corrupted far too easily far too soon. If Victoria is going to be corrupted so much so soon, Katy needs to be a far worse influence than she currently is.
Writing - 1/5
In desperate need of an English proofreader as the writing is painful to read & is nothing short of horrid. The VN is over a year old (first post in the thread is March 15, 2020) & has had an update so there's no excuse for it to still be in this state. Literally everything is wrong from sentences not making sense, spelling errors, not understanding human speech in English to the point it sounds robotic/wrong, unnecessary conversation & I could go on. I think adding even some feminization to the dialog could go a long way & create more realism to the speech. In a game that is based around the 'good girl gone bad' cliche, I think some calmer language for Victoria is necessary until she gets worse or eventually becomes bad. Another issue is the font as it's hard to tell if the character is having a thought as it's hard to tell if it's in italics or not.
Art - 5/5
Everyone is stunning! Victoria & Katy are simply gorgeous. Backgrounds are great. Perfect.
Final Thoughts
Besides the writing being completely horrible & the lack of pacing that is necessary for a story of the "good girl gone bad" trope. It's still early enough in development to still have a lot of potential to be something good if not excellent with proper direction. The story does need some tweaking. What I would do is go back & make Katy an even worse influence as the reason why Victoria cheated so soon which can be done by rewriting & changing the dress Katy bought Victoria to something more skimpy.
Pros:
- Good concept
- Everyone is beautiful
- Follows the "moving to the city" trope well
- Has a lot of potential
Cons:
- Writing is horrible, even the title
- Story is lacking & needs pacing but it's fixable
- Bad font
- MC is more neutral than good for the "good girl gone bad" trope
Overall Rating - 3/5