88stanford88

Engaged Member
Aug 12, 2022
2,556
2,721
The title of this game is literally Village Slut TRANSFORMATION meaning the girl is transforming into a slut, she's not supposed to be a slut from 1st second or even 1st couple of episodes. The game is not finished yet so for this game you, as you mentioned before, should wait in order to enjoy your slut at her fullest.
I would understand your disappointment if the game was fully made and the girl didn't become a slut but this game can have much more than 8 episodes that there are right now so I can't understand you at all
yes I know but almost 2 years are gone... 2 years are not enough to start the title story????
I was in this thread since the start!... now I'm back to check if the transformation is started
I'm only interested in the transformation and the reasons that make her decide to become a slut
 

swiver

Active Member
Sep 13, 2020
618
573
yes I know but almost 2 years are gone... 2 years are not enough to start the title story????
I was in this thread since the start!... now I'm back to check if the transformation is started
I'm only interested in the transformation and the reasons that make her decide to become a slut
In terms of progress, you're back in good time.
As for the transformation and character development, realism, etc. I'm afraid it's been quite disappointing.

Nonetheless, it's worth it for the MC. Best description of how I feel about it is it's like a bad movie with a great actress...

Seriously no offence meant, just my opinion... Still technically count as a fan.
 

88stanford88

Engaged Member
Aug 12, 2022
2,556
2,721
In terms of progress, you're back in good time.
As for the transformation and character development, realism, etc. I'm afraid it's been quite disappointing.

Nonetheless, it's worth it for the MC. Best description of how I feel about it is it's like a bad movie with a great actress...

Seriously no offence meant, just my opinion... Still technically count as a fan.
and what about tags planned?

Thanks
 

88stanford88

Engaged Member
Aug 12, 2022
2,556
2,721
I love well written stories... (I do not like explicit sex without a plot like western porn by legalporn or similar adult-movies production houses)
but the "slow-burn" type is very very old style in the adult game and is acceptable only in VANILLA stories

The Title of this game is not vanilla... and planned tags are not vanilla for sure

I prefer stories which surprise the auduenca with sudden fast-burn...for example, an epic sex scene of Lily overdoing it with alcohol and being drunk she falls into wanting to have sex...but the next day thinking about what she did makes one realize the true character of a young woman... but after that the story goes back to being slow-burn again includingwith an introspective view of the female protagonist who before bed wonders why she was stupid enough to get caught up in the vortex of her unexpected sexuality...and then gradually begins to think about what would happen if she decided to listen to her dark side...

this must be done in the EP4 in my opinion... now we are in EP8 and i was thinking that a bit of the dark-slut side of Lily was already starting

I like stories with sudden escalations that achieve the effect of capturing even more those who, like me, are looking for an adult story with explicit scenes--- The title is meaning a lot for me I like transformation... but transformation must not be just the ending of the game
Paths must be separate since the start of the story in order to get a believable transformation

As I wrote in a post that I got deleted,(without any reason) it is impossible for me that a girl who does not like to have sex would turn into a slut if she wasn't one before...
teenage girls are sluts right away because they provoke men and they do it because they are already sluts...
other girls who are shamed as teenagers will never become sluts...and even after being raped they go back to being even more demure by harboring hatred for men

That is why i think that is quite unrealistic transforming a shy girl into a slut if she was not before

Slow-burn must be mixed with fast-burn to create a believable story

My opinion of course

Thanks
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: vimmers

88stanford88

Engaged Member
Aug 12, 2022
2,556
2,721
Why.... you should care less about what i write...use the ignore button....
Do you think i need help? I respect your opinion...
and i had forgotten to say the following about the game

I think a bad girl who becomes a good girl by repenting of what she did would be a more believable transformation....
anyway thanks for reading my constructive criticism of the story of this game

Thanks
 

swiver

Active Member
Sep 13, 2020
618
573
and what about tags planned?

Thanks
It's accurate: the upcoming is still not there. Not sure about voyeurism, don't remember, otherwise, aside from thematic stuff, all current tags have been seen in the game.

To be clear, I find the pacing has not been too slow. Generally the structure of a good story has been followed to a T. It's the execution that's the problem; there's probably only one convincing scene (and I might be positively biased because of the outfit and nature of the fetish_ it's where she's working behind the bar). I do not believe the struggle, I did not feel the resistance, I do not know how it was conquered. No character made the impact of its role on me (I've reviewed it in an earlier release, haven't changed my mind).

I'm mostly annoyed of how the decisions are made. We're here to see a story of corruption, through temptation or pressure. Dev decided that the critical moments should be chosen by us_ fair enough, makes it interactive, makes us play her role rahter than the role of her corruptor, alll director's choice and matter of taste... the issue there is simply I am neither tempted (that there's a win for my gaming or that the character actually desires something) nor am I forced by a consequence (like a bad end for example) or other circumstance to make that choice of "transforming"... )The result is essentially that I break the immersion and decide to click the button that shows me scenes; I am not making a choice in a story, just clicking open...

I've similar problems with Lisa's Investigation (I see you're a fan). There there's far more content, but that had a negative effect on me. I'm still keeping up with this VN and actually read, whereas I stopped playing Lisa since before the first party. Bad build up is one thing, adding an avalnche of confusin content to it is another.

One reason for optimism here is there if the text is rewritten it might become alright. Drastic change (in code and art) is not really necessary.

I do still recommend a playthrough, as it shines here (vanity exhibitionism) and there (a groping scene), while still not being overly long to make you lose your patience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 88stanford88

demidemon

Member
Aug 31, 2016
440
605
He was only gentle for a few moments, then he became a monster by the end. It also implies that there could be others who might not be so ‘gentle’, so will Lily's deflowering have blood then? It's a bit disingenuous, that's all.

Good writing is always “Show, don't tell.” Dialogues don't have much of an impact like visual confirmation does, which 99% of a VN depends upon... visuals!
quite a lot of women didn't bleed the first time they have sex, especially when they do sports that could stretch their hymens. They could also have masturbated before and stretched their hymens. Its not like they have a membrane in their vagina that break and bleed when they first have sex.
 

johnyakuza1

Well-Known Member
Jun 5, 2022
1,005
2,190
quite a lot of women didn't bleed the first time they have sex, especially when they do sports that could stretch their hymens. They could also have masturbated before and stretched their hymens. Its not like they have a membrane in their vagina that break and bleed when they first have sex.
That could be the case IRL... but we're talking about Lily here. The dialogue specifically suggests her hymen was broken in, which implies it was intact and not stretched out or torn before this... and Lily hasn't used toys or fingered herself at all. Anyways, the discussion is moot at this point... It could be a real possibility that the dev just doesn't have the DAZ assets for blood and didn't bother with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: swiver

mamaboiii

Active Member
Oct 13, 2018
572
1,699
Any progress on the updates ?
Dude. We just got an update.

But here's the latest progress on the next update anyways (totally real and no irony, nono):
"Hey guys, I, the dev, the real one, just released an update and spent three days reading stupid stuff (and nice feedback :)) on this pirate website. Now I need another three days for therapy and a bunch of new braincells. Anyways, working on the next update afterwards, byeee. xoxo"

I love the carnage that happens in the thread when a good game updates :LUL:
 

swiver

Active Member
Sep 13, 2020
618
573
While it may not be an every day thing she did put some makeup on and a nice dress she looked so beautiful in this update
That was hawt! (do wish he showed the makeover with girls' harassing and embarrassing her but yea achieved "make me beautiful" phase on the road to bimbocation)
 

88stanford88

Engaged Member
Aug 12, 2022
2,556
2,721
It's accurate: the upcoming is still not there. Not sure about voyeurism, don't remember, otherwise, aside from thematic stuff, all current tags have been seen in the game.
Thank you for your very comprehensive replay ... your talk about the story of this game and I really appreciate the exchange of opinions ON TOPIC
For this paragraph I reply that I am waiting for the promised and not yet active tags ...

To be clear, I find the pacing has not been too slow. Generally the structure of a good story has been followed to a T. It's the execution that's the problem; there's probably only one convincing scene (and I might be positively biased because of the outfit and nature of the fetish_ it's where she's working behind the bar). I do not believe the struggle, I did not feel the resistance, I do not know how it was conquered. No character made the impact of its role on me (I've reviewed it in an earlier release, haven't changed my mind).
I played EP 3 and I knew right away that the developer did not want to delve into the introspective view of the main girl ... but instead wanted to describe the places where the story takes place ...
I find this approach of writing in an illustrated story very wrong because a few pictures are enough to describe the world in which the story takes place this is a good way to write a text-based book but certainly not suitable for a visual novella...
personally I prefer stories where you get straight to the point by letting illustrations describe the location and facial expressions describe the hidden emotions of the characters...
only a textbook has to dwell on descriptive aspects in words
I'm mostly annoyed of how the decisions are made. We're here to see a story of corruption, through temptation or pressure. Dev decided that the critical moments should be chosen by us_ fair enough, makes it interactive, makes us play her role rahter than the role of her corruptor, alll director's choice and matter of taste... the issue there is simply I am neither tempted (that there's a win for my gaming or that the character actually desires something) nor am I forced by a consequence (like a bad end for example) or other circumstance to make that choice of "transforming"... )The result is essentially that I break the immersion and decide to click the button that shows me scenes; I am not making a choice in a story, just clicking open...
I agree...with this and that is why before download again the game i'll wait for some of my favourite tags to be included
I've similar problems with Lisa's Investigation (I see you're a fan). There there's far more content, but that had a negative effect on me. I'm still keeping up with this VN and actually read, whereas I stopped playing Lisa since before the first party. Bad build up is one thing, adding an avalnche of confusin content to it is another.
Lisa was great up to the first part (season1) the new part2 is confused you are right but that game has the merit of having a lot of content.... is I downloaded it when the party was about to start...there are not too many unnecessary descriptions there...the dialogues to lead you to choose and decide to open all the scenes...
for the record I don't like games where making a choice means losing content...
and I'll give you another example of a poorly written game....

Mila AI... in this game the choices preclude you from gradually exploring the different paths...
basically if you choose the NTR path you preclude yourself from exploring the NTS path... in my opinion netorare and netorase are two very complementary fetishes and can coexist in the story by changing soo some dialogues

I really love LTI and i think there is still room to back the story in a very good one!
if you think about it Lisa Total Investigation is the exact opposite of this game with the first chapter being made in less than 1 year... on the other hand Village Slut Transformation which despite being in its 8th episode still hasn't taken off and it's been almost 2 years
this tells me that the author of Lisa had clear ideas of the story while here, the author seems to want to hide the meaning which is clear only in the title he chose...here the developer is tergiversating
The Title is perfect!!
One reason for optimism here is there if the text is rewritten it might become alright. Drastic change (in code and art) is not really necessary.
.. rewrite??? this meaning that this game will be delayed
the best way is to speed up the tags that aren't in the story yet...because it's obvious from your critique that the author doesn't know how to stretch the “broth” anymore...he's stretching the wine with water and the customers in his restaurant are noticing...if he keeps this up he's going to disappoint his entire potential audience IMO
I do still recommend a playthrough, as it shines here (vanity exhibitionism) and there (a groping scene), while still not being overly long to make you lose your patience.
I totally agree... but as you can see I lost patience because I realized that the story would take years to progress...but the more time passes...the worse it will be for the developer.
The title is perfect...but the execution of the work is lacking

I don't like games where the choices are; see the sex scene or skip it....
these kinds of stories only demonstrate the inability to create intermediate paths where the girl chooses to get laid and then eventually repents and goes back to pure,,, or to take the paths of sadomasochism, or engagement and then cheating on the boyfriend or deciding to create a stable relationship there always has to be a way for the protagonist to redeem himself from his mistakes or to take revenge for the wrongs done to him.
For example, a girl employed in a bar might even become the owner by having the boss arrested by whom she got laid by agreeing to do it for the customers

Thank you for talking about this game with me
I'm just trying to help... but i will wait for the other tag before write my definitive overview
 
  • Like
Reactions: swiver
4.10 star(s) 57 Votes