As so many times in my reviews, I have to call this game a HUGE missed opportunity.
It has all foundations to be absolutely amazing, yet it fails in such a bizarre way.
It's got interesting story premise, great selection of girls, good setting, amazing art style and plenty of variety.
So let's start with the good:
- Girls are hot - and decently varied in personality (this will also come as negative later)
- Art is beautiful
Now negatives:
- Sandbox - Just sigh. If not for hint system, I'd rate it even lower. 99% of the time it's impossible to know where to go.
- Quests - Find X ingredients. Find X books. Find X pieces of wardrobe. Find X pieces of rubbish (not making this one, actual quest!). So have fun clicking over and over looking for where stuff is.
- Sandbox part 2 - Where are quests? Lord knows. Have fun clicking, clicking, clicking until you accidentally run into something.
- Girls personality - What the hell? Game introduction: "You fell here, you're probably chosen one, we don't know what to do with you so learn magic with us". Literally next scene as you exit your room (no interaction with ANYONE at this point): "Ugh, I don't like you or how you act with other girls", "Ugh, someone stole my panties, I know it was you!". Keep in mind MC is in that world literally few hours, and ton of girls and people blame him for events he couldn't have done.
The only positive I can say here is MC outright says "I don't give a fuck about your world or your problems" in one of the convos. Words that are about the same as I felt at that point.
- Girl quests seem to be one-and-done. You get a conversation with 3 options. Select wrong, quest ends immediately, no points, no resolution, no repeats.
- Slay The Spire lite - Great idea. Horrible, horrible execution. It happens at the very start of the game (tutorial), then it's gone for hours, then all of a sudden there's a quest where it takes ton of time to finish it. It's slow, enemies have way too much health (thank heavens they hit like they're throwing pebbles so there's no risk of losing) and it's just not fun.
- Everyone is acting like a jerk. Both girls, students (this part makes sense) and especially teachers. There are maybe 2-3 friendly characters, others just use MC for pointless errands while also throwing insults his way.
It was so bad I decided not to defend girl getting bullied since I genuinely couldn't care any less. An elitist bullying others being bullied by bigger elitist? Sure, have it at.
So overall, amazing foundations completely ruined by sandbox, lack of content (or more specifically, difficulty of finding any content), too many tsunderes, fetch quests with way too much clicking, slay the spire that needs serious rebalance, story that disappears immediately after tutorial (as in, story is GONE, it doesn't exist after intro) and few other issues.
Might take a look at it in few years, it's not lost hope, with some serious changes this can be amazing game.