Recommending Western Sharing Games List

[Joshy92]

Your thread has more likes than mine, Johnny. Now I'm jealous.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

Your thread has more likes than mine, Johnny. Now I'm jealous.

I'm sure you'll be okay, what with 1400 pages to your name

 

[Joshy92]

I'm sure you'll be okay, what with 1400 pages to your name

Also, I sleep soundly knowing I have more cuck points than you. Sorry, dude, but there can be only one master cuck.

 

[BlenderGuy]

The slopyard's getting a big haul today

Resort of temptation i remember - I was frustrated early on as you had to have played all the prior games for the characters to make sense in the shared universe. Skye's model was always gorgeous tho.

How the Hell do you expect me to nut to slop, Johnny!?

Any advice??

 

[SinisterPortal]

This is no where near as bad though as with Daz games

Ive no idea what Daz is

 

[SinisterPortal]

I agree with most of them being absolute garbage, but so is McDonalds. I have to admit that I enjoy my occasional little guilty indulgence like a Milk Shake or AI rendered games like:

• Shadows of Ambition
• Moonripple Lake
• My New Girlfriend

But please don't rat me out for it...

btw I dunno if it's just me but I feel like there's a lot of movement in Moonripple Lake, it feels very cinematic for some reason. In comparison, both My New Girlfriend and Shadow of Ambition feel much more static. In the latter two, there's often relatively long monologues with the same picture on the screen, the face expression doesn't change through many phrases said by the character. I mean I get it, it's probably intentional, My New Girlfriend and Shadow of Ambition have this comic style, they even have actual comics in many scenes, but still I prefer this more 'lively' style of Moonripple. I'd say the only problem of Moonripple is that many side girls look too similar, but that's a problem of the AI model.

 

[SinisterPortal]

Actually, I have a question about the games on Pr0GamerJohnny 's list. If you remember, I previously asked about games where sharing is forced—for example, the couple is facing financial difficulties or something like that—but along the way the MC develops a fetish and starts enjoying watching. I asked about this because I really dislike the trope where the MC himself is the active initiator, especially in kinetic novels where, as a player, I have no control over how far things can go.


It turned out that there are very few games like this. People recommend Inn My Wife and Adelaide Inn (although in the latter the “forced” part is only in words—in reality the MC can refuse sharing without any negative financial consequences), and that’s pretty much it.


That’s disappointing, but after playing My Italian Slut Wife I realized that it’s actually fine when the initiator is the girl/wife herself, and the MC just supports her. Are there any other games like this?

PS: By the way, in Moonripple the MC’s initiative is handled pretty well—at first it’s Suzie who takes the lead, trying to flirt with a cop to get out of a fine. That ends up awakening the MC’s fetish, and later he’s the one asking her to tease other guys. Since the game actually lets you choose whether Suzie should “go further” in each spicy situation, it creates a nice experience overall. You don’t get the feeling that you’re playing as some jaded, messed-up cuckold like in many other games of the genre.

 

[WhiteVanDaycare]

Ive no idea what Daz is

This is

You must be registered to see the links

, it is used to generate the graphics for the majority of good quality AVN's out there.

btw I dunno if it's just me but I feel like there's a lot of movement in Moonripple Lake, it feels very cinematic for some reason. In comparison, both My New Girlfriend and Shadow of Ambition feel much more static. In the latter two, there's often relatively long monologues with the same picture on the screen, the face expression doesn't change through many phrases said by the character. I mean I get it, it's probably intentional, My New Girlfriend and Shadow of Ambition have this comic style, they even have actual comics in many scenes, but still I prefer this more 'lively' style of Moonripple. I'd say the only problem of Moonripple is that many side girls look too similar, but that's a problem of the AI model.

I think you hit it with the facial expression changes along with having a variety of graphics that change during the dialogues. Even just 3 images that are only a little different makes it feel more alive, in Moonripple's case they overlay the expressions during dialog screens. Not hard, but I agree it gives it a lot more depth.

That’s disappointing, but after playing My Italian Slut Wife I realized that it’s actually fine when the initiator is the girl/wife herself, and the MC just supports her. Are there any other games like this?

Careful now, you might become...

 

[SinisterPortal]

Careful now, you might become...
View attachment 5191750

Heh, well I disliked a lot of things about this game: the humiliation, the small cock trope, the fact that in many moments you have no control about what happens, not to mention the average-quality 3d-render. Overall this is a lot more "cuckold" game than I'd like it to be, but still, the fact that the MC is not the 'active' cuck and that what happens is more of the wife's initiative - this is what made it enjoyable to me.

 

[reidanota]

Heh, well I disliked a lot of things about this game: the humiliation, the small cock trope, the fact that in many moments you have no control about what happens, not to mention the average-quality 3d-render. Overall this is a lot more "cuckold" game than I'd like it to be, but still, the fact that the MC is not the 'active' cuck and that what happens is more of the wife's initiative - this is what made it enjoyable to me.

I couldn't go past the first scene with the wife. The entire build-up is humiliating af, and when you fuck her, she's all condescending and you cum prematurely. It's not just that the wife takes the initiative, it's that she teams up with his bullyish friends in "teasing" the MC in a demeaning manner, interspersed with some "come, come, now, don't be like that, it's all good fun" moments. It's a game for masochists, unless it changes completely after those first scenes. The dev's answers in their thread suggest that he likes to taunt people who came to their game looking for something other than a beta cuck MC. I'm all for devs who do their own thing regardless of forum users, but this one shows the middle finger a bit too much.

 

[SinisterPortal]

I couldn't go past the first scene with the wife. The entire build-up is humiliating af, and when you fuck her, she's all condescending and you cum prematurely. It's not just that the wife takes the initiative, it's that she teams up with his bullyish friends in "teasing" the MC in a demeaning manner, interspersed with some "come, come, now, don't be like that, it's all good fun" moments. It's a game for masochists, unless it changes completely after those first scenes. The dev's answers in their thread suggest that he likes to taunt people who came to their game looking for something other than a beta cuck MC. I'm all for devs who do their own thing regardless of forum users, but this one shows the middle finger a bit too much.

Aye, it gets especially horrible on the second day with humiliation and everything, but it improves a lot towards the evening of that day where the MC finally gets full control over what happens - the wife won't even make out with the bull on that evening without the MC's permition. And on the third day it's finally feels like a proper sharing game - e.g. you can totally block the nasty friends from having fun with the wife.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

Actually, I have a question about the games on Pr0GamerJohnny 's list. If you remember, I previously asked about games where sharing is forced—for example, the couple is facing financial difficulties or something like that—but along the way the MC develops a fetish and starts enjoying watching. I asked about this because I really dislike the trope where the MC himself is the active initiator, especially in kinetic novels where, as a player, I have no control over how far things can go.


It turned out that there are very few games like this. People recommend Inn My Wife and Adelaide Inn (although in the latter the “forced” part is only in words—in reality the MC can refuse sharing without any negative financial consequences), and that’s pretty much it.


That’s disappointing, but after playing My Italian Slut Wife I realized that it’s actually fine when the initiator is the girl/wife herself, and the MC just supports her. Are there any other games like this?

PS: By the way, in Moonripple the MC’s initiative is handled pretty well—at first it’s Suzie who takes the lead, trying to flirt with a cop to get out of a fine. That ends up awakening the MC’s fetish, and later he’s the one asking her to tease other guys. Since the game actually lets you choose whether Suzie should “go further” in each spicy situation, it creates a nice experience overall. You don’t get the feeling that you’re playing as some jaded, messed-up cuckold like in many other games of the genre.

I doubt you'll find many titles like that here or other enthusiasts in that vein - as I'd describe that as more of an "ntr-lite" kind of setup, or like "ntr and mc lets it happen". On the various ntr lists I'd bet you find better suggestions for that kind of setup.

Though I am somewhat confused by your question, because on one hand you're saying you don't like the mc to be the initator, but on the other hand you enjoy when mc (and therefore the player) has choices presented to them about how far to go. These things seem contradictory to me, since generally an mc with less autonomy will be more or less along for the ride - and these tend to be the games I think of as hardcore submissive simulators, whereas when mcs have more autonomy they can usually pick which events they want to partake in.

 

[SinisterPortal]

Though I am somewhat confused by your question, because on one hand you're saying you don't like the mc to be the initator, but on the other hand you enjoy when mc (and therefore the player) has choices presented to them about how far to go. These things seem contradictory to me, since generally an mc with less autonomy will be more or less along for the ride - and these tend to be the games I think of as hardcore submissive simulators, whereas when mcs have more autonomy they can usually pick which events they want to partake in.

When the MC is the initiator - he pushes things, when the LI is - the MC just allows things, I prefer the latter if the player doesn't get much choices, but when it's handled like in Moonripple (you got almost full control) - I don't mind the MC as the initiator

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

When the MC is the initiator - he pushes things, when the LI is - the MC just allows things, I prefer the latter if the player doesn't get much choices, but when it's handled like in Moonripple (you got almost full control) - I don't mind the MC as the initiator

I'm even more confused now

So when you play the games, do you want to have more or less control as the player?

 

[SinisterPortal]

I'm even more confused now

So when you play the games, do you want to have more or less control as the player?

hehe, generally - yes, the more control - the better. But it's rare when they give you control in this kind of games. Usually it's like in Blurring the walls or Atelier Sakura games - you say you don't want her to do certain thing - game over (happy ending - you are not a cuck!). Games where you get to choose how far things will go in each h-scene is rare - I really can only name Moonripple and partially My Slut Italian Wife (the latter half of the game). Tho with MSIW it will likely change in the future, as reidanota pointed out - the dev likes hardcore maso stuff and likes to 'troll' players that don't like it

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

hehe, generally - yes, the more control - the better. But it's rare when they give you control in this kind of games. Usually it's like in Blurring the walls or Atelier Sakura games - you say you don't want her to do certain thing - game over (happy ending - you are not a cuck!). Games where you get to choose how far things will go in each h-scene is rare - I really can only name Moonripple and partially My Slut Italian Wife (the latter half of the game). Tho with MSIW it will likely change in the future, as reidanota pointed out - the dev likes hardcore maso stuff and likes to 'troll' players that don't like it

Oh that's not my experience at all - perhaps you have more experience in japanese style games than I do or that's more normal there? I dunno.

Just running down the top of my list, Deliverence, yup, you either encourage kat or dissuade each event, all separate...LSS, definitely have choices and subchoices for all the share scenes.... Same with exciting games, same with between worlds etcetc.

That's why I was confused - most of these games (and my personal preferences) are far away from traditional japanese-style "netorase" stories, where you have this feeble meek mc who says in a shaky voice to his wife "ummm.... would you be interested in..." Ofc, there are still some on list like that (stay away from lisa investigation ), but for the most part there's plenty of games where a more dominant mc with autonomy is the default.

 

[SinisterPortal]

Oh that's not my experience at all - perhaps you have more experience in japanese style games than I do or that's more normal there? I dunno.

Just running down the top of my list, Deliverence, yup, you either encourage kat or dissuade each event, all separate...LSS, definitely have choices and subchoices for all the share scenes.... Same with exciting games, same with between worlds etcetc.

That's why I was confused - most of these games (and my personal preferences) are far away from traditional japanese-style "netorase" stories, where you have this feeble meek mc who says in a shaky voice to his wife "ummm.... would you be interested in..." Ofc, there are still some on list like that (stay away from lisa investigation ), but for the most part there's plenty of games where a more dominant mc with autonomy is the default.

Good to know, thanks. I mostly play eastern stuff because I don't like 3d render CGs, especially facial expressions and animations in them (they look super unnatural and usually opposite of hot). Part of the reason I'm all for AI CGs - at least we get more western games with 2d CGs, this is already a pro.

I skimmed through the list and games with the most natural looking graphics are usually IR cuckold stuff, damn. E.g. from 3DCG games I think Hotwife Ashley has the best looking body shapes, the most natural looking movement, poses etc. But it seems very cuckold-leaned.

Club Detention also looks good too, but the theme is, like, harem sharing?

Sins of Night looks good and story seems interesting

Medical Special Care - average graphics but big ass FMC looks alluring.

The Cure for Madness - looks good but no sex scenes among screenshots so can't really tell

Our Red String - the only 2d but mostly about cheating, heh

Do you remember which of these have choices?

PS: tried Hotwife Ashley just to check the graphics - I was wrong praising it, lol, it's prolly below average even. The screenshots tricked me.

 

[blkcrow20]

I couldn't go past the first scene with the wife. The entire build-up is humiliating af, and when you fuck her, she's all condescending and you cum prematurely. It's not just that the wife takes the initiative, it's that she teams up with his bullyish friends in "teasing" the MC in a demeaning manner, interspersed with some "come, come, now, don't be like that, it's all good fun" moments. It's a game for masochists, unless it changes completely after those first scenes. The dev's answers in their thread suggest that he likes to taunt people who came to their game looking for something other than a beta cuck MC. I'm all for devs who do their own thing regardless of forum users, but this one shows the middle finger a bit too much.

Same. horrible game.

 

[Dessolos]

Yeah I may like my Italian Slut Wife alot but it's more of a guilty pleasure sharing AVN for me but then again i really like teasing so it works for me because of that. I can see how it would be to much on the humiliation side for some tho ( not for me) . tbh the only AVN ive played the is to much on the humiliation side for me is the scene in PE where Julia makes you wait outside while she fucks the MC's friend.

But back to my Italian Slut Wife my main problem it tries to tip toe to much between NTR and NTS on the NTS path , where I wouldn't be surprised if NTS turns into NTR at some point. But despite it's flaws I like it as a guilty pleasure sharing game more than games like TACOS ( granted still need to play the rework , but I hated the original so much never got around to it yet)

 

[CursedByAll]

I'd welcome hear others opinions, would you take the tradeoff of twice the development time to get the better looking ai art above? Would you accept twice the development time for the better looking daz art?

I certainly am happy to wait, in the pursuit of quality, whether that is for story, balance of paths, or renders.

AI or Daz? That boundary is being crossed, slowly but surely, with the integration of AI into Daz and Blender stuff, and also the artistic ambitions and dedication of a few quality AI artists. I just want them to look good, really.

My preference is still Ren'Py/Daz/Blender 3D animated, but like any good slut, I'm not exclusive, lol. Some AI is brilliant, and yes, the AI slopyard is aptly named, because a lot of it is. But I could point to a few shitty Daz games too (well, more than a few tbh)

Some really good stories have shitty art, which I have to question whether to play because it hurts my eyes.
Some exceptional art needs a better script, otherwise its a comic at best, but definitely a missed opportunity.

On a reality side-note, story and script, is as equally important as renders are, no matter the art style used (though I am exclusively Ren'Py now). Balancing paths, if they exist, is really important for me, (I mean congruent development) and I am definitely happy to wait for that.

Congruent? If a game has 3 paths, and I am only playing one, I will wait until dev catches up with my path, even if it takes 4 or more updates. But a good dev will give a bit of each path in each update, keeping the flow alive for all players, not just some. Though I know that's hard and takes more time.

Kinetic doesn't bother me at all, if the story, characters and renders are good. As long as dev doesn't turn me off at some point, only having a few choices (and no paths) is ok sometimes. I mean even heavily optioned games sometimes have all wrong (for me) choices anyway, and that is worse in my view.

So yeah, give me quality please, I have the time, and can be very patient if the reward is there.