Recommending Western Sharing Games List

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

They usually fall on one of two categories, helpless cuck MC struggling to accept his "fetish" of seeing his LI be taken by other guys, or dominant MC corrupting a reluctant LI into fucking other men. So far, only in "western" games have I found the sharing game played by both partners with equal agency and with no hidden agendas.

This 100%, and a big part of why I have my preferences this way in addition to the art. I feel like "eastern" games are much less comfortable with ambiguity of status or magnaminous power dynamics. The idea of "there must be a higher and a lower, a winner and a loser" feels deeply culturally entrenched.

 

[CursedByAll]

"eastern" games "there must be a higher and a lower, a winner and a loser" deeply culturally entrenched.

And this is exactly the crux of the difference in approach.
It is a cultural heritage in Asia, and is the expected norm, by almost everyone in the region.
Whereas many "western" societies (Europe, the Americas, and other western styled demographics) have a completely different approach of equality and co-operation, almost compassionate, mostly loving.
Exceptions are perhaps BDSM scenarios, but even they differ again in the approach around permissions.
It is a different mindset, borne from a different upbringing and society.

 

[reidanota]

Describing Ben as a lover is very appropriate in that VN.
It builds, tension...

Oh, that's hideous, that tension seems to me like a weakening of the couple's relationship. One can see it as a challenge to overcome, but it suggests NTR vibes. Would have been more inclined to play that game if you'd said that "one, the other or both" were according choices you could make in the game.

 

[reidanota]

It is a different mindset, borne from a different upbringing and society.

You may have a point. I'm sure even in the global internet culture, education and group culture still are a factor. I once mentioned netorare in a post at loverslab.com, about a mod called Troubles of Heroine. Got a reply from a japanese user who was excited that the non-japanese public was aware of the term - it seems like it was perceived as cultural heritage by that user, at least.

Read another "theory" that suggested manga and hentai follow strict, tried-and-proven commercial formats, and that the Japanese AVN industry was much more established and professional, producing a constant flow of stories that meet high demand.

I wonder if Korean manhwa follow the same trend? These cultures are both alien to me, but judging strictly from the art style, Korean drawing looks a tiny bit less cartoonish, suggesting they might be less formal about taboo subjects in general. I'm not passing judgement. Japanese made it an art of hiding sexual themes in plain sight with rituals and cuteness, and all of it is interesting.

 

[reidanota]

I also dislike it equally when the sharing options / guys suck and the MC just lets things happen cause he is made to be a loser. I like some balance maybe not someone that is a total Alpha but just not a loser. The MC from A life worth living comes to mind unless you play the cheating path.

I often fall back to words like assertive or confident, rather than dominant, for that same reason. Sometimes it's the FMC that puts me off. If she's too invested in her own cravings and acts as if the MC didn't matter, I call it a miss. She may well be neither a QoS nor a total slut, but the kind of cuckoldry where the FMC has free pass to follow her attraction to others and the MC is just expected to enjoy it, not my thing.

I do have a guilty curiosity for a scenario where the MC finds his significant other cheating, and immediately discovers he enjoys it, not because he's a loser, but because he's got a grip on his own game and uses the fact that the FMC is oblivious of his awareness of the cheating, to his own advantage. This requires a rather dominant MC, capable of a bit of manipulation, plotting ways to have fun with the situation and, in the end, to reclaim his LI and himself cuck the lover/bull out of the picture. This could be fun to play, alas, not the kind of tropes NTR fans are usually interested in, as it would mean a plot twist that turns the NTR into either NTS or loyal endings. Anyone know a game like this? If an author really could pull an MC capable of reclaiming his LI and who also avoided the tropes of broken marriages, making the NTR entirely of the LI's own doing, and making her a likeable character only through the MC's eyes, where she couldn't otherwise save herself from being seen as a bitch, I'd be down to checking it out, but this is the kind of "ramification" that doesn't get filtered by tags. Certainly would also lend some meaning to a "compassionate" MC

approach of equality and co-operation, almost compassionate, mostly loving.

 

[Logan1377]

I often fall back to words like assertive or confident, rather than dominant, for that same reason. Sometimes it's the FMC that puts me off. If she's too invested in her own cravings and acts as if the MC didn't matter, I call it a miss. She may well be neither a QoS nor a total slut, but the kind of cuckoldry where the FMC has free pass to follow her attraction to others and the MC is just expected to enjoy it, not my thing.

I do have a guilty curiosity for a scenario where the MC finds his significant other cheating, and immediately discovers he enjoys it, not because he's a loser, but because he's got a grip on his own game and uses the fact that the FMC is oblivious of his awareness of the cheating, to his own advantage. This requires a rather dominant MC, capable of a bit of manipulation, plotting ways to have fun with the situation and, in the end, to reclaim his LI and himself cuck the lover/bull out of the picture. This could be fun to play, alas, not the kind of tropes NTR fans are usually interested in, as it would mean a plot twist that turns the NTR into either NTS or loyal endings. Anyone know a game like this? If an author really could pull an MC capable of reclaiming his LI and who also avoided the tropes of broken marriages, making the NTR entirely of the LI's own doing, and making her a likeable character only through the MC's eyes, where she couldn't otherwise save herself from being seen as a bitch, I'd be down to checking it out, but this is the kind of "ramification" that doesn't get filtered by tags. Certainly would also lend some meaning to a "compassionate" MC

I absolutely agree that the scenerio of a male MC finding out that his wife/gf has been hooking up with someone else and getting turned on by it can be a great intro to a bigger story or picture, so long as it develops from there, and leads to things like swinging/open relationship/everyone getting in on the action and just living a more open, sex filled life in general. You need a confident MC who knows that he's also sexy and desirable to make it work. The problem is that it so often turns into the MC being a weak loser who loses all of his masculinity in the process.

 

[redoubt27]

It is a different mindset, borne from a different upbringing and society.

I postulate the "eastern" mindset is closer to reality; while the "western" mindset is the fantasy, the exception to how "sharing" plays out in reality...
And I prefer less reality, and more fantasy in my choice of VNs...

 

[Captain_America]

QC to HR - "Houston, we have a problem"

You think this list is about a "majority"?
Of the thousands of games on this site, both 2d and 3d, this list contains less than 100, of a specific genre and taste, and you somehow wanna talk of majorities?
No, what you want is your personal taste to be prioritised. Then, respectfully to you sir, I would remind you that this list is made by ONE particular member.
You can of course, go and make your own. Perhaps you might get some fans too? Who knows, right?

Oh..you did? In a totally different category? Cool....hows that going for you? Seems quiet over there to me at least, but I get it. You are busy.....ok.

My boy got fucking offended or something. lol Good lord Went into my post history and everything to find my recommendations thread that I don't maintain as much anymore due to getting a new job. My boy went from 1 to 100 REAL FAST. Chill the fuck out ding a ling. It was a recommendation, not a fucking personal attack.

 

[Captain_America]

100% - I'd appreciate people first asking themselves "Does the game I'm about to recommend or discuss look or feel very anime-ish?" If so, no problem, but there are other places to better discuss it - namely zeputsu's thread or hentai kishi's thread.
Unfortunately in the 2d flavor there are very few games I'd consider both having sharing content and being in a western style. I do enjoy these when I see them, there's just not enough of them to warrant demarcation right now.

I have Our Red String on the list, I wish the "Blurred Lines" guy hadn't given up, that was looking to be a spicy 2d swinging/sharing game. If you have other suggestions of western-flavored 2d games, I'm all ears, but AFAIAK that subset is pretty small.

If you want to look through my thread, you might find more 2D you'd be interested in. No clue if you'll like any of them or not.

https://f95zone.to/threads/western-...ilation-list-and-review.227100/#post-14957670

 

[redoubt27]

Oh, that's hideous, that tension seems to me like a weakening of the couple's relationship. One can see it as a challenge to overcome, but it suggests NTR vibes. Would have been more inclined to play that game if you'd said that "one, the other or both" were according choices you could make in the game.

good thing it's anime'ish and ain't gonna be on this list...

 

[reidanota]

I absolutely agree that the scenerio of a male MC finding out that his wife/gf has been hooking up with someone else and getting turned on by it can be a great intro to a bigger story or picture, so long as it develops from there, and leads to things like swinging/open relationship/everyone getting in on the action and just living a more open, sex filled life in general. You need a confident MC who knows that he's also sexy and desirable to make it work. The problem is that it so often turns into the MC being a weak loser who loses all of his masculinity in the process.

The problem is that it might never appeal entirely to one group or the other. Most NTR players enjoy and demand negative emotions, most sharing/swinging players (myself included) want to avoid them. If the game started with being cheated on, either the author spoilered enough, or they released the full game in one go. I wouldn't like to invest in a game unless I were pretty sure the ending would be to my liking, and with no dread and gloom or any negative emotions along the way. I mean, I can see all sorts of problems with making a game like that, but I'd love to play it.

I postulate the "eastern" mindset is closer to reality; while the "western" mindset is the fantasy, the exception to how "sharing" plays out in reality...
And I prefer less reality, and more fantasy in my choice of VNs...

Exactly. Games can be all about indulging in the what ifs, so why shouldn't they The NTR guard uses realism as an argument when it suits them, but I bet 99% of them are playing to satisfy their sadistic or masochistic fantasies, not to examine the boundaries and constraints we all experience in real life.

good thing it's anime'ish and ain't gonna be on this list...

I'd still love to play it if the story went otherwise. Greedy as it sounds!

 

[redoubt27]

I'd still love to play it if the story went otherwise. Greedy as it sounds!

Give it a few more updates, see how it goes.

 

[CursedByAll]

My boy got fucking offended or something. lol Good lord Went into my post history and everything to find my recommendations thread that I don't maintain as much anymore due to getting a new job. My boy went from 1 to 100 REAL FAST. Chill the fuck out ding a ling. It was a recommendation, not a fucking personal attack.

Haha...nah man, just trying to suggest you stay in your own lane while on your little power-trip about what is "best".
I mean, sorry to suggest the obvious, but you know search is there for a reason right? To look for shit?
This thread is in the same forum as yours even, so anyone can find what they like, all for our own individual tastes.
Oblivious.....

 

[blkcrow20]

Not a fan of those BIG balloon boobs.

 

[AlfieT84]

Anyone play NTR Chat - My Girlfriends Travel? Picked it up today but it sounds like it is moving from what seemed like a mutual open relationship right into chaotic relationship breakdown territory. To be fair, the creator used the word NTR even if this game starts off much more in the NTS realm. Also the MC is already outrageously cheating, because he isn't updating Elle, and worse he's allowed a psycho girl to believe he is her one true love.

Pity if it goes off the rails. Amusingly Devin's weird proxy cuckold game is kind of fun but it is fun because Devin is just the side chick. Ultimately she's disposable so the fact she's blatantly setting up the MC as a future replacement for her husband she can openly cuckold is irrelevant. You can enjoy the chaos and say "lol you were always disposable" at the end.

However if Elle is going to outright distance herself from the MC as well then the whole context of the game changes. Kind of hoping the complaints are a storm in a teacup. Expect the worse though because the worse tends to happen

 

[redoubt27]

Anyone play NTR Chat - My Girlfriends Travel? Picked it up today but it sounds like it is moving from what seemed like a mutual open relationship right into chaotic relationship breakdown territory. To be fair, the creator used the word NTR even if this game starts off much more in the NTS realm. Also the MC is already outrageously cheating, because he isn't updating Elle, and worse he's allowed a psycho girl to believe he is her one true love.

Pity if it goes off the rails. Amusingly Devin's weird proxy cuckold game is kind of fun but it is fun because Devin is just the side chick. Ultimately she's disposable so the fact she's blatantly setting up the MC as a future replacement for her husband she can openly cuckold is irrelevant. You can enjoy the chaos and say "lol you were always disposable" at the end.

However if Elle is going to outright distance herself from the MC as well then the whole context of the game changes. Kind of hoping the complaints are a storm in a teacup. Expect the worse though because the worse tends to happen

If it goes off the rails? Not sure it's ever been on...
Gave up on it after the "crazy" chick reappeared for the 3rd time in the recent update, completely ignoring the fact that I rejected her from the start... You can't even do a restart and reject her; the story forces her back in no matter what...
Cannot stand that happening in a story. No means no damn it. Don't just throw her back in and the story act like she's been a thing all along...

It has potential to be pretty good, and I think Elle and the MC will ultimately be fine.
Unless the dev decides NTR/Elle cheating is more profitable...
But the story is a mess.
Right now, it is appropriately categorized in the "slopyard"...

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

Anyone play NTR Chat - My Girlfriends Travel? Picked it up today but it sounds like it is moving from what seemed like a mutual open relationship right into chaotic relationship breakdown territory. To be fair, the creator used the word NTR even if this game starts off much more in the NTS realm. Also the MC is already outrageously cheating, because he isn't updating Elle, and worse he's allowed a psycho girl to believe he is her one true love.

Pity if it goes off the rails. Amusingly Devin's weird proxy cuckold game is kind of fun but it is fun because Devin is just the side chick. Ultimately she's disposable so the fact she's blatantly setting up the MC as a future replacement for her husband she can openly cuckold is irrelevant. You can enjoy the chaos and say "lol you were always disposable" at the end.

However if Elle is going to outright distance herself from the MC as well then the whole context of the game changes. Kind of hoping the complaints are a storm in a teacup. Expect the worse though because the worse tends to happen

the only one of those newer dime-a-dozen ai phone gf sims I found worthwhile was "Sexting my Girlfriend". The rest just blend together

 

[CursedByAll]

the only one of those newer dime-a-dozen ai phone gf sims I found worthwhile was "Sexting my Girlfriend". The rest just blend together

Can't say as how much I would be interested in any long-distance relationship with sharing my LI, especially through some crappy phone interface. I would want hands-on action with the gf, just as much, if not more than, any other person. The whole phone thing feels more like NTR to me, sorry.... which I guess is ok for anyone who enjoys a pile of anguish, but that's just not my bent at all. I'm just here for the happy times, lol.
I mean, I would be ok with the occassional video via phone, while something was happening that I knew about, but even they would want to be seldom, not often.
Unless the guy is doing exactly the same to the gf, sending pics of the sluts he finds to the gf, and getting plenty of it.
Even so, the idea of playing a phone game on my pc sucks, just because of the aspect ratios, as most seem to be exclusively in portrait mode, which also blows my mind as the least favourable aspect on a phone.

 

[CainKovakhin]

Can someone recommend games where the love interest is fucked on the top of the MC?

 

[redoubt27]

Can someone recommend games where the love interest is fucked on the top of the MC?

A Happy Marriage [v1.0]
Paradise City [v0.3.1]

I think there are a few others that have similar scenes, but those are the only two that I remember off the top of my head.