What do you find more attractive in an incest-themed game: "aunt / nephew" or "mother / son?"

[Xenorav]

I am making a game and I have several renderings. the thing is that the main characters are quite similar, what you guys recommend?
I like the two thematics equally, but I want to read the opinions of others, you can suggest another thematic apart from those already mentioned.

 

[woody554]

I think there's a poll on it somewhere on this forum...

 

[215303j]

Aunt / nephew is hardly taboo, while mom / son is about the hardest incest taboo there is.
The stories should be vastly different.

 

[FeropsisFenarue]

It depends. Aunt/Nephew is less Taboo in general, but could be handled in some ways that are just as Taboo as mother/son.

I think the main difference is that people are willing to believe that Aunt/Nephew pairings happen more than Mother/Son.

I completely disagree that a mother has to be loving, in fact, there's a lot of asshole mothers out there, and its a lot more believable that an emotionally damaged mother commits incest with her son than one thats your perfect TV mom that spreads her legs for her son.

I think you'll get a lot more attention with a mom/son game than aunt/nephew game as a lot of 'teen boys' probably would find the mother angle a lot more taboo/erotic.

However, I think you could do a lot with an aunt as well, and its never really focused on much in games that well.

1) Pervert aunt that loves younger guys (corrputs MC)
2) Pervert aunt that already has incest experience with MC's dad (she's dad's sis)
3) Aunt that is suddenly given custody of hormone crazed teen boy and has no idea how to draw lines/punish the boy

Some mom scenarios that are rarely covered:

1) Mom hates the MC and tries to ruin his relationships eventually going as far as seducing him away from his girlfriends. This would be a gradual twist where the Mom has no sexual designs on her son, but uses sex to creep out his friends/girlfriends, dropping hints that she'd like to be part of a 3some, or that her son is a pervert, ect - and then slowly realizes that she'd actually enjoy the MC being sexually deviant.

2) Mom is in the middle of a mental breakdown and uses sex as a way of keeping men in her life, or sex to avoid her problems. The MC can be a little bit of a shitbag or in trouble at school and the mom uses sex to keep him in line.

3) Mom has previous incest experience and is actually fine with incest (its her kink) and she's been dropping hints on MC but he's maybe too chicken to go for it.

Mother or Aunt is probably fine, but as Thailf stated, with the Aunt you'd probably need to make the Aunt something more than the 'girl next door' to get people interested in it.

 

[Xenorav]

I completely disagree that a mother has to be loving, in fact, there's a lot of asshole mothers out there, and its a lot more believable that an emotionally damaged mother commits incest with her son than one thats your perfect TV mom that spreads her legs for her son.

I think you'll get a lot more attention with a mom/son game than aunt/nephew game as a lot of 'teen boys' probably would find the mother angle a lot more taboo/erotic.

However, I think you could do a lot with an aunt as well, and its never really focused on much in games that well.

1) Pervert aunt that loves younger guys (corrputs MC)
2) Pervert aunt that already has incest experience with MC's dad (she's dad's sis)
3) Aunt that is suddenly given custody of hormone crazed teen boy and has no idea how to draw lines/punish the boy

Some mom scenarios that are rarely covered:

1) Mom hates the MC and tries to ruin his relationships eventually going as far as seducing him away from his girlfriends. This would be a gradual twist where the Mom has no sexual designs on her son, but uses sex to creep out his friends/girlfriends, dropping hints that she'd like to be part of a 3some, or that her son is a pervert, ect - and then slowly realizes that she'd actually enjoy the MC being sexually deviant.

2) Mom is in the middle of a mental breakdown and uses sex as a way of keeping men in her life, or sex to avoid her problems. The MC can be a little bit of a shitbag or in trouble at school and the mom uses sex to keep him in line.

3) Mom has previous incest experience and is actually fine with incest (its her kink) and she's been dropping hints on MC but he's maybe too chicken to go for it.

Mother or Aunt is probably fine, but as Thailf stated, with the Aunt you'd probably need to make the Aunt something more than the 'girl next door' to get people interested in it.

I'm new to this world of erotic material, I didn't even watch almost porn. But one day I gave a chance to a game around here and I liked it, it was thematic "incest" with aunt (I don't remember the name).
I also have fallen into a cliché, reading in some other posts I realized that my revolutionary story of the boy who arrives at his house after a while was very, VERY used... I honestly prefer aunt / nephew, but looking around here I see that mom / son is more profitable
I will make some adjustments to the story, and I will change several renderings of the introduction, the theme will be aunt / nephew which i think is a little less used.
Thanks man.

 

[Holy Bacchus]

Both.

I feel like with the Aunt/nephew dynamic, it can be easier to establish a sexual relationship, even if the Aunt is the Mom's biological sister, because there's a degree of distance there that makes the relationship feel less morally questionable despite the blood connection. Whereas with the Mother/son dynamic, it's more difficult but more rewarding because of the difficulty of starting a sexual relationship with your birth mother given the closeness of the existing Mother/son relationship. Also, the Aunt can be a useful "wingman" in pushing the Mom to accept the burgeoning sexual feelings she's beginning to have for her son and to not only embrace them but to act on them.

However, an Aunt/nephew dynamic where the nephew has been raised by his Aunt (preferably single) could be an interesting angle as there is a similar closeness to the Mother/son dynamic where stepping over that line could be more difficult but also just as rewarding as if it were a Mother/son relationship.

 

[Xenorav]

However, an Aunt/nephew dynamic where the nephew has been raised by his Aunt (preferably single)

A single aunt?... hmm.. a little danger wouldn't be bad , but you gave me a good idea where to direct the story, thanks man I love your avatar.

 

[khumak]

My favorite incest theme is actually blood related mother/daughter pair both fucked by unrelated guy. I don't mind the kind where the guy is related as well but for me the relation between the females is more important.

 

[FeropsisFenarue]

A single aunt?... hmm.. a little danger wouldn't be bad , but you gave me a good idea where to direct the story, thanks man I love your avatar.

I think the best scenario for the Aunt would be that the boy lived with his parents until about 10-12, right about the time he recognizes his aunt is attractive, but its a kid's crush. He knows she's pretty but isn't sure what to do about it. She notices the attention he's giving her, but its not creepy or wierd and maybe she flirts with him a bit, telling him he'll grow up to be handsome man because he's cute now, and his parents are attractive.

Then, as the boy starts getting those sexual thoughts for older women around him, suddenly his life is up-ended, maybe his parents go to jail (don't kill them, thats so cheap and overdone) for something silly like tax fraud that some business partner pinned on them. The boy then has to live with his aunt, who has no idea how to raise a kid, set boundaries or teach him about morals/decency.

So in comes a sexually charged teen boy into a hot maybe clueless woman's house, and things have been brewing for a while. Suddenly you are in the present time, the boy is 18, he's getting ready for college or maybe a trade school. His Aunt is sort of his mom, his closest girl friend, and also a HUGE sexual crush to him and he doesn't know how to handle the transition. Also, his parents could be getting out of jail at this time, and they are making plans for him to move back in with them while he's at school.

 

[Holy Bacchus]

A single aunt?... hmm.. a little danger wouldn't be bad , but you gave me a good idea where to direct the story, thanks man I love your avatar.

I mean, yeah, having her be married would be a good angle for the dangerous side of it and would certainly make it even more rewarding to essentially "steal" the Aunt from him, but I suppose it depends on how the husband is portrayed. If the husband is the typically cold, distant, workaholic who may also be cheating on their insanely hot wife or are impotent, then that coud be too predictable and make it too easy to get with the Aunt (granted, her being single is also easy, but it removes an often frustrating obstacle).

That being said, if the Aunt were to be in an (apparent) happy marriage, that could be interesting. Perhaps the nephew came to live with his childless Aunt and Uncle at age 15 after the death of his single mother, this way by the time he turns 18 he hasn't spent very long with either so that "distance" aspect is still there, especially with the Uncle making it easier for the MC to not feel not much guilt when going against him. Also, maybe the MC doesn't actively try to pursue her, but it simply happens naturally over the course of a few months and then the MC finds out that the "perfect" husband is actually having an affair so it makes her feel less guilty and finally pushes her over that edge into having sex with the MC, then she kicks the husband out.

 

[FeropsisFenarue]

Don't kill the parents. Its a much more risky situation the Aunt finds herself in if the parents are still alive and the choice could come back to haunt them. Plus you can always introduce the mom at a later point too

 

[Xenorav]

That being said, if the Aunt were to be in an (apparent) happy marriage, that could be interesting.

Don't kill the parents. Its a much more risky situation the Aunt finds herself in if the parents are still alive and the choice could come back to haunt them. Plus you can always introduce the mom at a later point too

You two read my mind, thanks both.

 

[morphnet]

why not do both? The visit did a pretty good job of it, maybe have a look to get some ideas

https://f95zone.to/threads/the-visit-v0-12-4-stiglet.10361/

 

[FeropsisFenarue]

why not do both? The visit did a pretty good job of it, maybe have a look to get some ideas

https://f95zone.to/threads/the-visit-v0-12-4-stiglet.10361/

The Visit doesn't really have much depth to copy from. Aunt visits, sexy times immediately begin. Mom is eventually convinced to join in. Its a good game from a porn perspective, but its cliche as fuck.

 

[Xenorav]

why not do both? The visit did a pretty good job of it, maybe have a look to get some ideas

https://f95zone.to/threads/the-visit-v0-12-4-stiglet.10361/

Oh, I played that game a few days ago, it's the game that made me enter this community.

 

[Xenorav]

The Visit doesn't really have much depth to copy from. Aunt visits, sexy times immediately begin. Mom is eventually convinced to join in. Its a good game from a porn perspective, but its cliche as fuck.

I agree with you, the story felt a bit rushed.

 

[konabwo]

any game with foursome? mom+aunt+nephew+son?

 

[woody554]

... I will change several renderings of the introduction, the theme will be aunt / nephew which i think is a little less used.

almost every single mom/son game has a slutty aunt opening her thighs for the nephew at a drop of a hat. just so you're aware it's also extremely common.

that said, while you'll see countless of complaints about the basic incest house setting (dead dad, stern mom, slutty aunt, asshole big sister, adoring little sister who you can't stop from fucking the mc), the numbers very clearly show it's by far the most liked scenario. the people who keep complaining about it don't usually even play incest games.

if you want to write some other incest story, I definitely think you should do exactly the one YOU want. but don't for a second think any 'original story' will get more fans just because it's a 'new' approach. it won't, they never do. the only crowd you'll please are the complainers, but they won't check it anyway because it has the incest tag.

 

[woody554]

I agree with you, the story felt a bit rushed.

it was the guy's first try and wasn't even meant to be a game. as I remember he started it to see if he could figure out how to make one, posted it here to get feedback, and people loved it and begged him to make it an actual game. so that explains a lot about it. still, huge props for finishing it, that almost never happens in this genre.

 

[Family Fun]

It depends. Aunt/Nephew is less Taboo in general, but could be handled in some ways that are just as Taboo as mother/son.

...
1) Pervert aunt that loves younger guys (corrputs MC)
2) Pervert aunt that already has incest experience with MC's dad (she's dad's sis)
3) Aunt that is suddenly given custody of hormone crazed teen boy and has no idea how to draw lines/punish the boy

Some mom scenarios that are rarely covered:

1) Mom hates the MC and tries to ruin his relationships eventually going as far as seducing him away from his girlfriends. This would be a gradual twist where the Mom has no sexual designs on her son, but uses sex to creep out his friends/girlfriends, dropping hints that she'd like to be part of a 3some, or that her son is a pervert, ect - and then slowly realizes that she'd actually enjoy the MC being sexually deviant.

2) Mom is in the middle of a mental breakdown and uses sex as a way of keeping men in her life, or sex to avoid her problems. The MC can be a little bit of a shitbag or in trouble at school and the mom uses sex to keep him in line.

3) Mom has previous incest experience and is actually fine with incest (its her kink) and she's been dropping hints on MC but he's maybe too chicken to go for it.

Mother or Aunt is probably fine, but as Thailf stated, with the Aunt you'd probably need to make the Aunt something more than the 'girl next door' to get people interested in it.

I like these ideas a lot and saved them in a Word file. I don't know that I'll ever be motivated enough to learn DAZ and Ren-Py sufficiently to both create something and not be intimidated by some of the spectacular art and complexity of existing games.