Well, I might as well get in on this.
Looking at it now a couple days later, I would probably switch Kimmy and Penny, but too lazy to go do it. Also funny that some characters (Millie for example) I gave high ratings based purely on looks, while some are up there based on pure awesomeness (Skye).
Since I refuse to cheat on Jamie, a couple of these girls I haven't met and some have had so little content so I just threw all of them in D ordered based on looks.
In previous tier lists I don't know that I have ever put a girl in E or F since that's for ones I don't really like and that really takes some doing.