Chalk boss

Member
Aug 31, 2024
450
4,014
311
Your assessment of Jacob is inaccurate. Your issue with him is because he's "too normal". He chose to go to the HOT party with MC because the alternative was shoving a vodka soaked tampon in his ass. John Boy also goes eventually. He didn't do much because the Alphas were there & that's a potential problem. He was able to get his own girl at the Dorm party.

And people say it's "creepy" that he listened to MC & Sage. How so? What was he supposed to do? Leave Derek because the MC is having sex? Put ear plugs in his ears that he didn't know he would need because he didn't know he was going to have to babysit Derek at the same time the MC was sleeping with Sage? He had an excuse to outside. It'd be creepy if he was outside listening for no reason. Considering Derek was able to cause a girl to be loud in a tent means it's not that difficult to do in the BaD universe.

People either don't like him for whatever reason. Maybe it's racial (unheard of). Maybe people are upset because he took his shot with Zoey. Or they want to implicate him because he is the least suspicious person. His room was damaged the most aside from the library which was a 2nd bathroom before MC moved in. Why would he willingly allow the destruction of artwork of his that would take a significant amount of time to create? Nick's room was damn near untouched & both of their rooms are next to each other.
Like I said Jacob is a blank slate. Tabula rasa. Nothing is known about him and you can't say for sure which side he's on.
He doesn't have his own arch, even though he's been in the fraternity for a long time, it feels like he's keeping to himself, just like Nick.
It's just that if you pay attention to the other characters they are always revealed in quite a lot of detail and you can say a lot about each of them. Jamie and Leon's line is one of the best in the game.
Only in ep10 did Jacob have his own line related to Zoey and that was quickly shut down.
I don't know if it's a flaw on the part of DPC who doesn't reveal him in any way or if it's just done intentionally to tell anything about him, especially if it turns out he's involved in all the trouble with the DIKs.
 

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
249
258
196
Like I said Jacob is a blank slate. Tabula rasa. Nothing is known about him and you can't say for sure which side he's on.
He doesn't have his own arch, even though he's been in the fraternity for a long time, it feels like he's keeping to himself, just like Nick.
It's just that if you pay attention to the other characters they are always revealed in quite a lot of detail and you can say a lot about each of them. Jamie and Leon's line is one of the best in the game.
Only in ep10 did Jacob have his own line related to Zoey and that was quickly shut down.
I don't know if it's a flaw on the part of DPC who doesn't reveal him in any way or if it's just done intentionally to tell anything about him, especially if it turns out he's involved in all the trouble with the DIKs.
You say that as if you have a lot of information on the rest of the DIKs besides Tommy & Derek.

  • What do you know about Rusty aside from his name, position, & that he liked Micha?
  • What do you know about Nick aside from his crush on Heather?
  • What do you know about Jamie? He likes botany & he's in a relationship with both Leon & Dany.
  • What about Leon? We know even less about Leon. He has a weird friendship / relationship with Jamie. Hobbies? Who has he slept with aside from Arieth?
  • What about John Boy? We know he's in a relationship with Elena & they like to party near nude. He's a good chef.
  • What do we know about Jacob? He is in school for artistry. He understands situations & tries to prevent things from escalating. He liked Zoey.
  • We probably know the most about Tommy. We know he has anger issues. We know he likes the cumpetition & partying with the strippers. He likes Lily & Tanya. He was in a relationship with Heather.

Look at the wealth of information we have on these non-blank slates. We know the last name of only 2 DIKs. What specifically do you know about the other DIKs that rule them out but leaves Jacob as a suspect? What has he done that was suspicious? If possible, can you not speculate & provide an instance he has shown himself to be untrustworthy.

I can easily list Nick as a suspect. Red herring or not. His room being practically untouched is a massive issue for me. The only DIK pic of him, he's wearing a mask.
 

Roger-a-Dale

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2024
1,785
2,548
332
Like I said Jacob is a blank slate. Tabula rasa. Nothing is known about him and you can't say for sure which side he's on.
He doesn't have his own arch, even though he's been in the fraternity for a long time, it feels like he's keeping to himself, just like Nick.
It's just that if you pay attention to the other characters they are always revealed in quite a lot of detail and you can say a lot about each of them. Jamie and Leon's line is one of the best in the game.
Only in ep10 did Jacob have his own line related to Zoey and that was quickly shut down.
I don't know if it's a flaw on the part of DPC who doesn't reveal him in any way or if it's just done intentionally to tell anything about him, especially if it turns out he's involved in all the trouble with the DIKs.
You have really weird expectations and values. You credit Leon and Jamie as having a story, but they are more of a running joke. They could happen but they haven't yet and might not. Jamie has Dany and his green room, but what is Leon without Jamie? What is Nick without his connection to Vinny? Sure he slept with Heather, but why would that drama count for more than Jacob's drama with Zoey? Why does John Boy and Elena's count when everything they do is completely in the background? What more is there to Rusty than his Burgmeister connection and failed attempts with Micha and Jill?

I'd say Jacob is on equal footing with most of the brothers at the moment. The two with significantly more presence are Derek and Tommy and the one with least is Leon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dontehall2023

dontehall2023

Member
Dec 16, 2023
249
258
196
I think all of this speculation here is due to boredom & waiting out the release. The Josy Maya revelation was a surprise because there was no indications that I saw that said they were in a relationship with each other. So to think that there's a chance that the culprit can't be anyone until it's revealed is wasted effort.

James can be dead or alive. There's no hard evidence any way. Same with who MC is related to. There's been nothing to this point that says he's related to Rusty. Or anyone for that matter. The house that Jill's parents live in isn't confirmed to have been MC's mother's house. I may be wrong there but I thought they just said they bought it from a friend.

All of these theories & speculations will be revealed eventually (perhaps). And then we can go back to see what foreshadowing DPC added before the grand reveal. If any.

There's a total of 4 prominent non-white characters in this game. Two are essentially prostitutes, one is a stripper & the 4th can't just be a guy, he has to be a traitor. Very interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StrontiumBob

grey_shadow

Member
May 21, 2022
244
274
131
I hope Sally isn't a virgin. It wouldn't make much sense for Sally to have been in a relationship with Magnar for an undeterminable period & still be a virgin. I know how some people feel about love interests with a sexual history, but can we not have all of the women be virgins.
I got the impression that the Sally/Magnar relationship was more on Sally's side, with Magnar too focused on his studies to notice the body being thrown at him...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Znar26

FalconLover420

Engaged Member
Nov 23, 2020
2,643
3,034
419
But who is making this about race tho? We are discussing at who can be the leak based on their behavior, trust me if it was based on race there would been all the race jokes, statistics and etc.

Primary Leaker => Nick

Possible Leaker => Jacob, Tommy and others.
 

TuckeredOut

Member
Nov 17, 2018
470
1,094
231
I think all of this speculation here is due to boredom & waiting out the release. The Josy Maya revelation was a surprise because there was no indications that I saw that said they were in a relationship with each other. So to think that there's a chance that the culprit can't be anyone until it's revealed is wasted effort.

James can be dead or alive. There's no hard evidence any way. Same with who MC is related to. There's been nothing to this point that says he's related to Rusty. Or anyone for that matter. The house that Jill's parents live in isn't confirmed to have been MC's mother's house. I may be wrong there but I thought they just said they bought it from a friend.

All of these theories & speculations will be revealed eventually (perhaps). And then we can go back to see what foreshadowing DPC added before the grand reveal. If any.

There's a total of 4 prominent non-white characters in this game. Two are essentially prostitutes, one is a stripper & the 4th can't just be a guy, he has to be a traitor. Very interesting.
I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong on either account but I believe the Royce's were told by a family friend about the house being up on the market and needing to be sold quickly and not that they knew who lived there personally. And also I think it was at least insinuated that the photo from the diary was taken at Lynette's house before she was forced to move away.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,719 Votes