I quite enjoyed this update.
Tilly scaring the bejesus out of Karina was hilarious and fantastic. Just fantastic.
Don't ever change Tilly.
Look into Karina's past as to how she got recruited into Misericordae was quite interesting too (I do wonder whether we'll see it for each of the nuns?)
I admit the whole "reincarnation" throws an interesting new wrinkle in the theory as to the whole why there is a big age gap between MC and Maddy.
As UncleFredo said getting Maddy's soul back is something which would be better if it is resolved sooner rather than later, but I think also explanation of the whole age gap would be better off explained when Maddy comes back to us, so the story can focus on MC's own story and his new relations with the nuns, and Maddy (that is, if she ends up being a LI).
One thing I would ask is, would there be actual human antagonists in the game?
So far we've seen a creature (Karina's memories), mention of Wendigo.
While the previous Priest was murdered, there has been no indication of how he was murdered (and by what exactly).
Not to mention Maddy mentioned the one who broke her back was a "she" (I mean that could mean a monster as well, but I'm getting a bit of suspicion it could be a powerful human magic user who did that number on Maddy).
Anyway, it was fun and looking forward to next update in May.