- Apr 22, 2019
- 2,223
- 1,937
I can appreciate a naturalistic evolution of a narrative. Situations can evolve and relationships change because of that evolution to a point. Foreshadowing and clear narrative choice can go a decent way to keeping a story fresh. When you get to the point of drastic genre shift (romance to horror or tragedy for an example) I feel the author isn't being honest with the initial advertising.For me it really depends on how its done.
In Rewrite the change is very natural, while remaining a clear cut point. All elements were hinted before, hidden in plain sight or even carefully exposed. Then, the shift happens and the story feels smooth about it.
I dont believe House in the Rift will go to those details, but sometimes for stories not to stalemate, you need to flip the board.
As a personal example, my spouse wanted to see A Constant Gardener and sold it to me as "a romance featuring Rachel Weiss". To say I was disappointed with the outing would be an understatement.